CELESTIALS Remastered - Holy, Radiant, and Deeply Passive-Aggressive - RPGBOT.Podcast S5E98
Nov 17, 2026
The team cracks open the heavens and explores all things Celestial—those upper-planar beings with immaculate vibes and judgmental glowing eyes. From the serene beauty of devas to the bureaucratic nightmare of Inevitables, this episode dissects how Celestials work in your TTRPGs: their lore, how to use them as plot devices, and what happens when your party tries to seduce them (again).
This episode originally aired on August 15th, 2025, and we're currently working to upload our episode backlog. For the latest from the RPGBOT.Podcast, find us in your favorite podcatcher.
Full show notes for this episode are available on RPGBOT.net: https://rpgbot.net/celestials-remastered-holy-radiant-and-deeply-passive-aggressive-rpgbot-podcast-s5e98/
Find us on socials and stuff:
🦋 https://bsky.app/profile/rpgbot.bsky.social
⏰ https://www.tiktok.com/@rpgbotdotnet
🔍 https://RPGBOT.net/
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
The statuesque figure stands a dozen
0:02
feet tall. Their broad and handsome face
0:04
gazes heavenward, but you feel as seen
0:07
as if they were staring at you. Their
0:10
body looks iridescent, like it's made of
0:12
pearl, but on closer examination, you
0:14
see that they have a golden skin
0:16
scrawled with tiny opalescent wounds.
0:19
Both of this mighty being's hands rest
0:22
on the pommel of a great sword, easily
0:24
twice the length of most humans. Not a
0:26
muscle moves, but the white feathers of
0:28
their two great wings ruffle in a breeze
0:31
that you do not feel. This description
0:33
entitled Planetar is brought to you by
0:36
[music] D Describe. D Describe ready
0:38
roleplay. Go to describ .com/rpgbot
0:41
and use code rpgbot5 at checkout to get
0:44
$5 off your first subscription payment.
0:48
Welcome to the rpgbot.podcast. I'm
0:50
Randall James, your emissary angel, and
0:52
with me is Tyler Kamstra.
0:54
>> Hi everybody.
0:54
>> And actually lie.
1:02
[laughter]
1:07
All right, Tyler, what is happening?
1:09
>> Tonight we are going to discuss
1:12
celestials. So previously we've done
1:14
some episodes on various creature types
1:16
that we've always found interesting and
1:18
tonight we thought it would be fun to
1:19
look at celestials. Now this is
1:21
frequently a creature type that you
1:23
might not view as an antagonist. They
1:27
might appear in some kind of strange
1:28
places in your games. So we're going to
1:31
look at like what makes them neat, how
1:33
to use them in your stories, how you can
1:35
interact with celestials as a player,
1:38
you know, mechanically, narratively, all
1:39
those things. We're just going to see
1:41
what's cool and we're going to make it
1:43
cooler.
1:43
>> I'm really looking forward to this
1:44
conversation because I feel like there's
1:45
a lot of awesome stuff we can do both
1:48
mechanically and in roleplay bringing
1:51
celestials into more games. Kind of a
1:53
peek behind the scenes when we were
1:54
prepping the card. Like I said to Tyler,
1:55
Tyler, is there an adventure that you
1:57
can think of where celestials played
2:00
part of it that you liked. And Tyler,
2:02
unless you thought of something down
2:04
that now and then you were like,
2:05
I can't think of anything. Ash, I want
2:06
to put the same question to you. Like,
2:08
is there an adventure that you played?
2:10
Actually, I'm going to I'm going to do
2:11
this in a two-parter. Is there a first
2:13
party D&D or Pathfinder adventure you
2:16
played that centered on angels? And then
2:18
we'll follow have you had a good time
2:20
with them?
2:20
>> Well, you know, just not to spoil much,
2:23
but we actually on my other podcast Crit
2:26
fails, we actually talked about
2:28
celestials and how there's not a lot of
2:30
them
2:31
>> Mhm.
2:31
>> because, you know, people don't tend to
2:33
use them as enemies or antagonists in
2:35
their games. So to answer your question,
2:37
Randall, no. I haven't played any
2:40
published adventures with celestials,
2:42
but then again, I haven't played many
2:43
published adventures. But I have run a
2:45
game, co-DM'd a game actually with my
2:48
roommate B where celestials were the
2:50
main antagonists because it was an evil
2:53
game and they were fighting to bring
2:54
down the celestial court. So celestials
2:58
were a big part of that. And that's
2:59
where our main frustration why we did a
3:01
episode on celestials because it was
3:03
like there's like five celestials in the
3:06
main book and it's like we need more.
3:09
We need more than this.
3:10
>> There's no variety here.
3:12
>> Nope.
3:12
>> Cool. Awesome. All right. So let's hop
3:14
into it cuz I think we're going to have
3:15
some good ideas on this show. I guess to
3:17
lead with Tyler, I think you had a
3:18
pretty interesting trichotomy of
3:20
celestials worth talking through.
3:22
>> Yeah. So so as I went through the maybe
3:25
longer than most folks realized list of
3:28
celestials that have existed in the
3:29
history of D&D, Pathfinder, and adjacent
3:32
games, I roughly categorized them into
3:35
three groups. So you have your
3:37
biblically accurate angels. Like a lot
3:39
of celestials are very much inspired by
3:42
Christianity, Catholicism specifically.
3:44
And like if you go to cathedrals and be
3:46
like, look at those angels on the walls,
3:48
a lot of that made it straight into D&D.
3:51
First group is the biblically accurate
3:53
angels. These are the crazy ones that
3:54
are like concentric rings covered in
3:56
eyes with a sun at the middle.
3:58
>> Yeah, turns out angels in biblical
4:00
mythology are kind of cosmic horror.
4:03
>> Yeah.
4:03
>> Yeah, exactly that.
4:04
>> [laughter]
4:05
>> It's called
4:06
>> It's a
4:07
Be not afraid. How could I not be?
4:09
>> [laughter]
4:09
>> What?
4:11
What is this? What are you? Why are you
4:13
surrounding me in three dimensions?
4:14
>> Oh, you look at I look at you with my
4:17
eyeballs and my head explodes.
4:18
Fantastic.
4:19
>> Pretty much. Yeah, so biblically
4:21
accurate angels, category one. So
4:23
category two is biblically inaccurate
4:25
angels, but the ones you'll see in
4:26
churches. So these are your like
4:28
basically people with wings and maybe
4:30
superpowers. You know, sometimes the
4:32
swords are on fire. Usually they have
4:34
white feathered wings, cherubs, etc.
4:37
>> Yeah, I think this is the the good
4:39
group, right? The the emissary angel is
4:40
a good example of this
4:42
where or I should say maybe the astral
4:44
diva is that we have the first group of
4:46
angels where it's like, okay, they're
4:48
now terrified. Now let's actually make
4:49
sure they hear the message. Send the
4:51
good-looking ones.
4:52
>> [laughter]
4:54
>> Yeah, that's about right. All of these
4:55
angels in every piece of official art
4:58
are flawlessly attractive depictions of
5:01
humanoids, but also they have wings.
5:03
Sometimes their skin's orange. I don't
5:04
know.
5:05
>> Yeah, I I loved the the read from
5:07
Describe on the Planetar. It's like the
5:09
the Planetar, it's like the nominated
5:11
most likely to just stab you to death as
5:13
opposed to actually talking through or
5:14
solving any problems. But even then it's
5:16
like, right, like chiseled jaws, perfect
5:18
bodies, you know, great swords, as big
5:20
as two people. Like it's like they're
5:21
they're lovely if they didn't hate me.
5:23
>> Planetars are basically described as
5:25
like big statues come to life, so makes
5:28
sense. Like especially if you're going
5:30
based off of classical Renaissance
5:32
depictions of angels in that Romanesque
5:35
like statuary, then yeah, idealize male
5:39
form essentially or female form,
5:42
whichever.
5:43
>> [laughter]
5:44
>> All right. So category three is
5:47
biblically inaccurate angels, but like
5:49
you'd see in D&D, not like you'd see in
5:51
a church. So this gets a little a little
5:53
further from category two. So this is
5:56
where you'll see things like lantern
5:57
archons, which are basically a a
6:00
celestial light bulb that shoots lasers.
6:02
Hound archons have been one of my
6:04
favorites since like the 3.0 monster
6:06
manual. So imagine a paladin. They have
6:09
the head of a golden retriever. It's
6:10
red, inexplicably, but they still really
6:13
like great swords and smiting. Why do
6:16
they exist? No idea.
6:17
>> No, that sounds awesome. It feels like
6:18
it's almost somebody was like, we need a
6:20
different idea for celestials. Let's be
6:23
inspired by the Egyptians, except for
6:25
what if Clifford the Big Red Dog
6:27
[laughter]
6:28
was was the head of this thing?
6:31
Let's do that. [laughter]
6:33
>> Yeah, all right.
6:35
So so D&D has has a good aligned plane
6:39
that is inhabited by intelligent
6:43
animals, which I if I remember right,
6:44
that's where hound archons come from,
6:46
but they haven't made their way into
6:47
fifth edition, so I don't know where
6:48
they stand in the lore right now. But
6:50
yeah, there's all kinds of celestials
6:52
that are basically humanoids with animal
6:55
heads and magical powers. And hey, if
6:57
you're listening to this sometime in
6:59
late 2024, you might see that as a
7:02
playable option in the player's
7:03
handbook. Who knows what's going to
7:05
happen with 1 D&D. We also have cool
7:07
stuff like solars, which are just like,
7:09
okay, what if we took those winged
7:10
humanoid angels and just turned it up to
7:12
11? Like basically a 20th level cleric
7:15
with a bow that shoots lasers that do a
7:18
million damage. Yeah, they're totally
7:21
strong.
7:21
>> Wait, aren't the sol aren't the solars
7:23
the ones where it's like, you know what,
7:24
two wings, two wings, that's blasé. What
7:26
if we had four wings?
7:28
>> [laughter]
7:28
>> Honestly, I don't remember.
7:30
>> Don't mess with the heavens, y'all.
7:32
>> Yeah.
7:33
[laughter]
7:33
Yeah,
7:34
the highest CR fiend that doesn't have a
7:37
specific name is like CR 21. And then
7:40
solars are like CR 25 or something
7:43
that's like that. They're they're
7:45
strong. They're pretty cool. All right,
7:46
let's see. So there's also celestials
7:48
that don't fall neatly into these
7:50
categories. Like a lot of deities, if
7:52
they have stats, are a celestial or I
7:55
think like evil deities are typically
7:57
fiends like Orcus. There are some like
7:59
deity adjacent things like there are
8:01
these creatures called imperians who are
8:03
described as the children of good
8:05
aligned gods. They're huge sized, look
8:08
like statues. They're super strong. I
8:10
don't know why they exist and why they
8:12
aren't actually deities, but there they
8:13
are in the monster manual.
8:15
You've got
8:16
>> It it's like an answer to the Titans.
8:18
Like, ah, okay. We we need big things to
8:21
be scared of, but they're not going to
8:22
be gods, but still like they'd be a lot
8:24
of fun to go and fight.
8:25
>> [laughter]
8:26
>> Something like that, yeah. There's
8:27
kodols which are like your Aztec winged
8:30
serpents that can cast cleric spells for
8:32
some reason. There Kirin which are based
8:35
on a a Chinese mythological creature
8:38
>> Where are the longs?
8:40
>> I don't
8:41
>> Big
8:42
>> They're in Pathfinder.
8:43
>> Yeah, the big dragons. Like the the
8:45
celestial I guess the answer is that if
8:48
longs existed in D&D, they would be bit
8:51
more powerful than gods.
8:53
[laughter]
8:54
That's kind of how they're described.
8:58
>> Yeah, I mean Pathfinder has those like
8:59
the the book Treasure Vault centers
9:02
around a long dragon, one of the
9:05
varieties. She has black scales. I don't
9:08
remember the names of the different
9:09
varieties. There's so many. But yeah,
9:11
she you know, she has the the second
9:14
largest collection of magical artifacts
9:15
in the multiverse. So, you know, she's
9:17
kind of got her stuff together.
9:19
>> Actually, I'm not familiar with this. I
9:20
want to ask for for clarification. When
9:22
you say longs, like literally just it's
9:24
a long dragon?
9:25
>> So, well long is the is Chinese is the
9:28
Chinese word for for dragon. So,
9:31
it's their version of dragon. So, when
9:33
you think of like the dragon that's more
9:35
serpentine, kind of floats through the
9:36
air, doesn't have wings, that's that's a
9:39
that's a long.
9:40
>> And so if I think of like Chinese New
9:42
Year or Lunar New Year dances, like that
9:44
sort of thing, the really cool dances
9:45
they do with that that's a long
9:46
depicted. Or I guess even in Breath of
9:48
the Wild, there there's all of the
9:50
longish dragons flying that would also
9:52
maybe be considered a long.
9:53
>> Yes. I was going to go for Gyarados, but
9:56
those are much better examples.
9:57
>> Gyarados would would kind of be a long
9:59
as well, yeah.
10:01
>> [laughter]
10:02
>> All right. So, Kirin, honestly I I did a
10:06
lot of like Wikipedia depth of
10:08
and could not figure out like where did
10:10
these from? Because it seems like
10:11
there's a a million different versions
10:13
of what they're exactly supposed to be,
10:15
but they are they do originate in
10:16
Chinese mythology. If you've seen the
10:20
the Rules Expansion triple book set,
10:22
like the picture of Mordenkainen riding
10:24
that golden critter on the front, that
10:26
is a Ki-rin. They're good aligned and
10:28
they like to participate in the fight of
10:30
good versus evil. So like they're one of
10:32
those creatures that's like, wait, why
10:34
haven't you solved all of our petty good
10:36
versus evil problems? I don't know.
10:38
We'll get there. And then unicorns.
10:39
>> bucket with the rest of the wizards.
10:40
>> Yeah. And then unicorns are are
10:42
celestials for
10:43
>> Which makes some reason no sense. They
10:45
should be fae.
10:47
>> 100% yeah, absolutely.
10:49
>> Mhm.
10:50
>> Yeah, depending on which version of D&D
10:52
and Pathfinder you're using, basically
10:53
anything that was born in one of the
10:55
good aligned planes can be a celestial.
10:58
You can have celestial badgers. In 3.0
11:00
you summoned them at level one. It was
11:02
great. It's like, behold my celestial
11:04
badger.
11:05
>> Okay, wait. In in that case, if there
11:07
are spiders in the heavens, could I have
11:09
celestial spiders?
11:10
>> You 100%
11:11
>> Fantastic. How does that make you feel?
11:13
>> Bad.
11:13
>> Okay. [laughter]
11:15
Yeah, you have to wonder if there's ever
11:16
a
11:17
celestial rat problem.
11:21
>> [laughter]
11:23
>> All right. So we've hit on a bunch of
11:24
different creatures. I skipped over
11:26
Valkyries, which was listed in our
11:28
bullets. Like Valkyries are a good
11:29
example of the celestial. Like they
11:31
don't come from Catholic mythology, you
11:34
know, Norse mythology. They're
11:35
functionally like warrior angels sort
11:37
of. I don't know. I'm not an authority
11:39
there.
11:39
>> Yeah, I I love Valkyries, but I do not
11:42
think they are in base 5E. I think but
11:44
you can get a version of them from Tome
11:46
of Beasts. So shout out to those guys.
11:49
>> All right, Kobold Press with the win
11:50
once again.
11:52
All right. So yeah, like we've hit on a
11:54
bunch of creatures. Like they they have
11:56
a lot of cool stuff going for them. When
11:58
when you have to think about your world,
12:00
when you have to think about your game
12:02
in especially in D&D and Pathfinder
12:04
where it's established that for sure
12:06
these places exist, like there is a
12:08
plane called Celestia where there's all
12:10
of these angels that just hang out, you
12:12
have to give some thought to what are
12:14
these creatures doing all of the time?
12:17
Like they live forever. They're
12:18
incredibly strong in a lot of cases. Why
12:21
aren't they here cleaning up all of the
12:22
various messes and solving all of the
12:24
problems? And like just that alone can
12:27
present some really really cool
12:29
storytelling devices. And then, you
12:31
know, beyond that a lot of these things
12:32
have really really cool stat blocks.
12:34
They'd be a lot of fun to fight, a lot
12:36
of fun even to use as an ally. Like hey,
12:38
your party's in a pinch, a hound archon
12:40
shows up to tank for the party or
12:42
something. I don't know.
12:43
>> Yeah, I can imagine having like a cool
12:45
magic item like used once and it goes
12:47
away. But like if everything gets really
12:48
bad, Clifford the Big Red Dog in your
12:51
corner ready to go.
12:53
>> I'd summon Clifford the Big Red Dog.
12:54
>> Yeah, that would be great.
12:56
>> [laughter]
12:57
>> Weirdest dream.
12:58
>> I mean it seems like the only reason
12:59
they gave stats to celestials is so that
13:02
we have stat blocks that we can use to
13:04
summon planar ally and summon steed.
13:07
>> I don't know. Evil games exist. Every
13:09
once in a while you need you need some
13:11
angels to fight.
13:11
>> one, didn't we? Isn't Pegasus a
13:13
celestial?
13:14
>> Oh, you're right it is. Yeah, like I I
13:16
didn't do a perfectly comprehensive
13:17
list. I tried to like do a little splash
13:19
of everything. Like I'm not going to
13:21
list off everything in the 8 million
13:23
bestiaries for Pathfinder.
13:24
>> But the reason why I bring it up is
13:26
because I was wondering why they put I
13:28
was going to say that's probably why
13:29
they put unicorn as a celestial so that
13:31
you could summon it as a steed because
13:32
that's the only thing that you could
13:33
conceivably use as a steed. But then I
13:35
remembered Pegasus. So still, why
13:37
[clears throat] did you put unicorns as
13:38
celestials?
13:39
>> Uh weirdly you can't summon a unicorn as
13:42
a steed in 5E. You could in third
13:45
edition cuz they were like CR 3. In
13:47
fifth edition they're like CR 12 or 13
13:49
or something like that. They have
13:50
legendary actions. Like they're they're
13:52
a serious thing.
13:54
>> [laughter]
13:54
>> Yeah, I mean that's cool and all but
13:56
boo.
13:59
>> [laughter]
14:00
>> So let's talk about a a little bit. Like
14:02
why would a celestial get involved in my
14:04
game? What what am I doing that all of a
14:07
sudden oh, there's a celestial here and
14:08
either they're very happy to be talking
14:10
to me or they're not very happy to be
14:11
talking to me.
14:12
>> I think in any normal game probably not
14:16
going to deal with celestials until high
14:17
level. And it's either going to be
14:19
through Find Steed, Planar Ally, or like
14:22
trying to They're They're like the
14:23
McGuffin pointer outer. So like
14:25
[laughter] you must go
14:27
>> It's perfect.
14:28
>> You must go and find the ancient sword
14:31
of Glibber Flock de Blah and use it to
14:33
destroy Ganon. I don't know. Um
14:36
[laughter]
14:37
The uh
14:37
>> Geoffrey. You just killed Geoffrey.
14:40
>> Geoffrey the Dark.
14:42
Behold [laughter]
14:43
Behold his one weakness.
14:46
Hygiene. Anyway. [laughter]
14:51
The shampoo
14:53
The shampoo of cleanliness.
14:56
Anyway. Or you are trying to break into
15:00
heaven, I guess. Because when you get to
15:02
high levels, you're probably plane
15:04
shifting into Elysium at some point.
15:05
That's just going to happen.
15:07
>> [laughter]
15:08
>> It's It's what you do.
15:09
>> Yeah.
15:09
>> Wait. No, I'm I'm just imagining a
15:10
high-level wizard cast casting wash
15:12
wash. [laughter]
15:17
No, actually Okay, one more piece of
15:19
this. Like I I can 100% imagine playing
15:21
Like we have a cleric in the game right
15:22
now. I guarantee you if if I looked at
15:24
that cleric and said, "Hey, what deity
15:26
do you serve?" They would look at me and
15:27
say, "I don't know. I don't even think
15:29
that's written on my character sheet." I
15:30
can imagine like a celestial showing up
15:32
just to be like, "Do you remember any of
15:33
the tenets of religion? Do you What are
15:35
you even doing? Like you have all of
15:36
these gifts and you're you're you're
15:38
what? You're like You know, you you're
15:40
shaping water. That That's what I see
15:42
you do every day. I Why?"
15:44
>> [laughter]
15:44
>> Look, two-thirds of that cleric's spells
15:47
are Fireball, and the other third is
15:49
Fire Extinguisher.
15:50
>> I guess that is useful.
15:52
But yeah, I I can 100% imagine just
15:54
occasionally using an angel to pop in
15:56
and it's like, "Do you Do you remember
15:58
[laughter]
15:59
anything we talked about last time I was
16:00
here?" Which I guess is really just the
16:02
McGuffin pointer outer with extra steps.
16:03
>> Yeah. Yep. You must turn
16:06
Geoffrey the Dark into Geoffrey the
16:08
Clean.
16:09
>> Also suggest dandruff shampoo.
16:12
>> [laughter]
16:12
>> Head and Shoulders works wonders.
16:17
>> Yeah.
16:17
Okay, I want to summon planar ally in
16:20
the form of Ash to get us in this ad
16:22
break.
16:22
>> Okay. Remember, oh, Mustapha or whatever
16:26
his name was is on a horse. The
16:28
celestial guy who's telling you to get
16:29
head and shoulders is also on a horse.
16:31
Ad break. There you go.
16:32
>> Oh, that's great.
16:34
>> That is good.
16:35
>> That was terrible.
16:36
>> Look at your DM. Now look at me. Look
16:38
back at your DM. Now back to me.
16:39
>> Sadly, he is a DM.
16:41
>> I'm the DM that your DM could be. If
16:43
your DM ever washed their hair.
16:45
>> New dream. New dream. How do we get
16:47
Terry Crews to DM an episode for us?
16:51
>> [laughter]
16:54
>> That would be fantastic. I would love to
16:55
see Terry Crews
16:56
Actually, Matt Mercer, I believe, ran a
16:59
game for Terry Crews. It was wild.
17:02
>> [laughter]
17:03
>> Perfect. Got to go look that up.
17:05
>> Yeah, it was wild.
17:06
>> And we're clean.
17:09
>> [laughter]
17:09
>> Mr. Clean, Mr. Clean. Mr. Clean's got to
17:12
be a celestial, right?
17:14
>> I I'm pretty sure he's a planetar.
17:15
>> Yeah.
17:16
>> Clearly.
17:16
>> like it.
17:17
>> [laughter]
17:19
>> Yeah. Just smiting stains on your walls.
17:22
>> [laughter]
17:24
>> Terrible, absolutely terrible.
17:27
[laughter]
17:27
So let's talk about celestials from a DM
17:30
perspective and how we can actually use
17:31
them.
17:32
>> [laughter]
17:32
>> Yeah, cuz it's hard.
17:34
>> Yep.
17:35
>> All right. So we've talked previously
17:37
about the high wizard problem,
17:39
also frequently called the Elminster
17:41
problem, which is just there is a being
17:43
here who's allegedly good and immensely
17:47
powerful. Why are they not solving all
17:50
of the problems?
17:51
>> Well, you could just go the the Baldur's
17:53
Gate route and Elminster is just a
17:54
bumbling fool.
17:55
He just kind of does his own thing. He
17:57
only cares about cheese. So there you
18:00
go.
18:02
Mostly, I think the way that you I feel
18:05
like it's easier with celestials to
18:06
solve this problem than it is with high
18:08
wizards, cuz high wizards, they live on
18:10
the earth too, so why aren't they saving
18:12
it? But with the celestials, it's the
18:14
same reason why the gods don't directly
18:16
interfere because there is some sort of
18:18
dictate that necessitates that cannot
18:21
interfere as much as they would want to.
18:24
And planetars being the servants of
18:26
their gods are very much beholden to
18:29
their god's wishes. So if the gods like
18:30
no direct interference, then a planetar
18:32
is probably not going to directly
18:33
interfere.
18:34
>> I Okay, my worst nightmare as a DM
18:36
though is like having the players engage
18:38
in like in-game rules lawyering
18:41
about the the celestial code and this
18:43
agreement with that angel. It's like,
18:45
wait, okay, so this is really important
18:47
to to my god, right? Like we want to
18:49
have this happen. What you're telling me
18:51
to go kill Can't you just go kill the
18:53
guy? Like don't don't solve the whole
18:55
problem. When he's dead, we'll come in
18:57
and we'll we'll do the last bit.
18:59
[laughter] Then you didn't directly
19:00
interfere.
19:02
I I think it it's a hard sell job. Like
19:04
I I think what you're basically saying
19:06
when you're saying like, oh, but the
19:08
agreement that the standing pact says
19:10
that we can't do this, what you're
19:11
basically saying to your players is
19:12
like,
19:14
we're playing a game. Yes, you got
19:16
[laughter] to go do it.
19:17
Yeah, that honestly that might just have
19:19
to be the answer. Like it it doesn't
19:21
happen because this is a game and if
19:23
that happened, there wouldn't be a game
19:24
here. That that's reasonable.
19:26
>> I mean it it also another another way
19:28
you can do Yeah, you can do it that way,
19:30
but another way you can sort of just
19:31
about in universes it's hard to cross
19:33
the planes. Like it really is hard to
19:35
cross the planes. That's why devils make
19:37
deals with mortals because they can't
19:39
really directly cross into the plane
19:41
without some sort of special rift. And
19:43
it's why when demons create a rift in
19:44
our world, they exploit the heck out of
19:46
it. So planetars and other celestials,
19:50
even if there was like cracks in the
19:52
planes of reality to go through them,
19:54
they are pretty incentivized to not use
19:57
those, which is why you only see them
19:59
aiding adventures in very specific
20:02
circumstances like when you summon them
20:04
across the planes or a deity put them
20:07
there before the you know the the wards
20:10
around the prime material plane were put
20:12
in place or whatever to sort of act as a
20:14
mouthpiece and they are stuck in this
20:16
one position. So there's lots of
20:17
different ways you can probably explain
20:19
it. I think just making travel between
20:22
the planes very difficult is probably an
20:25
easy way to do that. So, yeah.
20:27
>> Yeah. I mean, most celestials can't cast
20:31
plane shift, so they can't just be like,
20:33
ah, yes, I'd like to visit the material
20:34
plane today. Here I go.
20:36
>> Mhm.
20:36
>> Just can't. Even even a lot of the
20:38
really powerful ones, like they can do
20:40
insane things, like high-level cleric
20:42
spells, cast wish, whatever, stuff like
20:44
that, depending on what game you're in,
20:46
most of them still can't cast plane
20:48
shift, so they can't Yeah, they can't
20:49
make the journey without somebody
20:51
bringing them along or without a like
20:53
permanent portal or something like that.
20:55
>> Although if they can cast wish, they
20:56
could say, gee, you know, I wish I
20:58
wasn't in this plane anymore.
21:01
>> I don't I don't know how many of them
21:03
can cast wish, to be honest.
21:05
>> Not many.
21:05
>> Yeah.
21:06
>> Again, like my my Spidey senses are
21:08
going off and in my head I'm like, okay,
21:09
it's really hard for you to cross
21:11
planes. That's the issue. Well, you're
21:12
here.
21:13
And you're just asking us to go down the
21:15
block, so like let's
21:16
>> Mhm.
21:16
>> But I I do take your point though, like
21:18
especially if if I can summon planar
21:19
ally, like maybe that's the answer. It's
21:20
like, I'm not going with you. I'm not
21:21
doing this for yourself, but tell you
21:23
what, you get in a pinch, things get
21:24
tough, I've got your back. You let me
21:26
know and I'll be here for you.
21:27
>> Yeah. Yeah, I mean summon planar ally is
21:29
a great way to get celestials, fiends,
21:32
fey, basically anything from the outer
21:34
planes. Like, you're over there, get
21:36
over here. We're going to have a
21:36
conversation. It's going to go badly for
21:38
me. It's going to be very very expensive
21:40
and I probably won't get what I want,
21:42
but we're going to try.
21:43
>> Yeah.
21:44
>> It's usually how this goes.
21:45
>> Yeah.
21:45
>> Man, I cannot tell you how many
21:48
adventures I've played through where
21:50
some portion of the plot was a
21:51
spellcaster cast planar ally, messed it
21:54
up, and now whatever thing they summoned
21:56
has run amok and murdered.
21:58
>> So like could you could you solve that
22:00
problem for us? That'd be
22:01
>> I mean, if you're summoning a planar
22:02
ally and they run amok killing a bunch
22:04
of things, something tells me you didn't
22:06
summon a celestial. You probably
22:07
summoned a
22:09
[laughter] Yeah. I don't Honestly, I
22:11
don't know why people always go for
22:12
summoning a demon. They probably just
22:14
figure, oh yeah, they're they're more
22:16
likely to negotiate with me to do my
22:18
bidding for something. Whereas the
22:20
celestials like, ah, I need you for
22:22
nefarious purposes such as theft and
22:25
accumulation of power in the celestials
22:26
like nah.
22:28
>> No.
22:29
[laughter]
22:29
No.
22:32
Followed, followed sometimes by stab.
22:34
>> [laughter]
22:35
>> Also true.
22:37
>> Okay, so talking about what we can do as
22:39
a DM with celestials. We talked about
22:41
the past like a little bit of like the
22:43
nonsense of a dungeon crawl and even the
22:45
fact that the game has gone meta with
22:47
that before of like well here's a
22:48
logical reason why these dungeons keep
22:49
getting reset. I I I say that to say
22:52
what do you need as guardians for a
22:54
dungeon that you want your folks to
22:55
crawl? You need a creature that can go
22:58
for immense amount of time being
23:00
completely bored out of their gourd.
23:02
Preferably they don't have to eat,
23:04
drink, sleep. Preferably they don't need
23:07
torches because it's hard to keep all
23:08
the torches lit all the time or maybe
23:10
they do. They do keep the torches lit
23:12
because they like the light. You see
23:13
where I'm going with this. I think
23:15
building a dungeon for a dungeon crawl
23:17
with celestials where the MacGuffins at
23:19
the center could be a lot of fun. Now
23:21
working out the dynamics of like okay I
23:24
have a mostly good aligned set of I have
23:26
a mostly good aligned party and they're
23:28
going to break in in this place to steal
23:29
something the celestials are guarding.
23:32
>> Actually that works pretty perfectly.
23:33
Even in a good aligned campaign you can
23:35
make that work. Maybe the only way to
23:37
beat the big bad cuz he's accumulated so
23:39
much power is to use a weapon of mass
23:42
destruction like a really powerful
23:44
weapon that the gods thought deemed too
23:46
risky and they put a celestial in front
23:48
of it to guard it. But she even though
23:51
it's risky it's kind of the only thing
23:53
that you can use to defeat the bad guy.
23:55
Or maybe it's a weapon of great power
23:58
from a legendary hero and the they put a
24:01
deva there to test any would-be heroes
24:04
to who are coming to grab it. They're
24:05
like okay you want to get claim the sort
24:09
of uber awesomeness first you must go
24:11
through me immortal. That's a pretty
24:13
epic fight.
24:14
>> Yeah.
24:14
>> Yeah.
24:15
>> There's no hate in this but you're going
24:16
to have to kill me to get this weapon
24:18
cuz that's that's where we're at at this
24:19
point.
24:19
>> Or
24:20
>> No I honestly like I love that. I think
24:21
that makes a ton of sense. I will say
24:24
what you described originally feels to
24:26
me a lot like I'm I'm I'm thinking
24:28
Infinity War, right? It's like I I have
24:31
this stone that I could use to fight the
24:33
baddie, except for I'm going to screw it
24:35
up and I'm accidentally going to let
24:36
them take it. And then the celestials
24:37
are going to be like, we told you. We
24:38
told you this would happen. That's why
24:39
we were protecting it so we didn't have
24:41
to worry about them.
24:42
>> mean that that is one way the story can
24:43
take where the heroes end up giving the
24:46
the main big bad the thing that he
24:48
needed to take over the world. But
24:50
that's a whole other story entirely.
24:52
>> [laughter]
24:53
>> Yeah, I think another fun thing that you
24:54
could do I'm thinking basically back to
24:56
a Diablo III, a single instance of a
24:59
celestial has just decided that they
25:01
don't agree with what the rest of the
25:02
celestials and maybe even their deity
25:04
are doing. And so they come to work with
25:07
you and and they become almost the voice
25:09
of the DM as an ally of like, oh, you
25:11
know, here's what you ought to be doing
25:12
next. Oh, going adventuring with you. If
25:14
I did that, the other celestials would
25:16
realize I'm interfering. So let's just
25:19
keep me on the down low. But
25:20
occasionally I'm going to be there as an
25:22
ally. I'm going to help you out. We're
25:23
going to see me in combat. And then of
25:24
course at that point you have a reason
25:26
where you might be engaging in these
25:27
fights with other celestials as well.
25:29
>> Yeah, I could I could see that being a
25:30
thing.
25:30
>> Yeah, more generally, if you want to
25:33
find a way to do celestials differently
25:36
and maybe have them as more enemies
25:39
rather than not not just in an evil line
25:41
campaign, a good resource, a good
25:43
example that I would point you to is
25:46
Final Fantasy XIV's expansion
25:48
Shadowbringers because their depiction
25:50
of angels is quite interesting. Cuz when
25:52
you think about it, angels in heaven are
25:54
kind of the enforcers of the status quo.
25:57
They have a vested interest in stasis.
26:00
And that is the entire point of these
26:02
particular angels called sin eaters who
26:04
are kind of more like eldritch
26:06
abominations whose entire point is to
26:08
spread light, kill anything that doesn't
26:11
have light in it and turn them into
26:14
celestials as well. So you can have a
26:15
really cool horror sort of oppressive
26:19
celestials. When celestials get
26:20
involved, it turns ugly sort of thing.
26:23
>> [laughter]
26:24
>> Yeah, that would absolutely make sense.
26:26
You know, infinitely powerful celestial
26:29
beings come down to a planet, decide to
26:31
out all evil, there's going to be
26:33
casualties and uh
26:35
>> Yeah, and their definition, their
26:37
definition of evil is pretty
26:38
narrow-minded, so
26:40
>> Mhm.
26:41
>> Yeah, it's it's like the scene in Dogma
26:43
where Ben Affleck and Matt Damon are
26:44
like walking around the table. They've
26:45
killed everybody in the boardroom and
26:47
they're like, you know, but you you you
26:48
are a good person except for you didn't
26:50
say God bless you and then [laughter]
26:52
Like there's a little bit of evil in
26:54
everybody on this planet and therefore
26:55
if we're going to purge all evil, we're
26:56
going to have to purge all sentient
26:57
life. I I will say it doesn't have to be
26:59
so extremist, right? It it could simply
27:01
be there is a vision for the future of
27:04
the material plane where 10,000 years
27:06
from now things are going to be really
27:07
great. But in order for things to be
27:09
really great 10,000 years from now,
27:10
things really have to suck 100 years
27:12
from now.
27:13
[laughter]
27:14
And so at at that point like we're at
27:16
odds cuz I'm a human and I live here and
27:20
my kids are going to live here and I
27:22
would like it not to suck. So could you
27:23
please stop your machinations,
27:25
celestials, or we're going to have a
27:27
fight.
27:28
>> Yeah, and and it's very easy for, you
27:30
know, immortal beings to have their
27:33
goals run counter to, you know, mortal
27:36
beings, but specifically for reasons you
27:38
called out, Randall, like me and my kids
27:40
live here. This sucks for me. I realize
27:43
there's a long game you're playing here,
27:44
but I don't want this. So it's very easy
27:47
for like two good aligned creatures both
27:50
with good intentions to have their, you
27:53
know, their intense run counter purpose.
27:55
We can also just take celestials and say
27:57
like, hey, this one's evil now. Like
27:59
there there's canon examples of that
28:01
happening. D&D has always been pretty
28:03
strict on alignment for like celestials
28:07
and fiends specifically
28:09
because like their their alignment is
28:11
essential to what they are as beings,
28:13
but there are a few examples. There are
28:16
devils called
28:18
Erinyes, Erinyes. It's one of those
28:19
words that you've only ever seen
28:21
written, so you have no idea how to
28:22
pronounce it. But they are they are
28:24
fallen angels that became devils and
28:27
instead of looking like humanoids with
28:29
white feathered wings, they're basically
28:31
humanoids with hawk wings that like
28:33
killing people. And then, of course,
28:34
there's Zariel who runs the first level
28:37
of hell, who is like she decided, hey,
28:40
I'm going to go participate in the blood
28:41
war and then she became a devil.
28:42
>> We've all been there.
28:43
>> [laughter]
28:44
>> I think there's also just ways that you
28:46
could take the well-intentioned
28:48
extremist and really play with it and
28:50
even make a celestial like a planetar
28:52
like the main big bad of the game. Like
28:55
maybe he, like Randall was saying,
28:58
there's a future that's coming 10,000
28:59
years from now, but before we can get to
29:02
that point, he needs to kill a lot of
29:04
people and wipe some cities from the
29:06
map. And he believes what he's doing is
29:08
ultimately in the best interest of
29:10
people, but he's kind of like a renegade
29:11
faction easily in a renegade faction of
29:13
celestials. So the other celestials and
29:15
the gods are still very much on the
29:17
players' side and being like, yeah, you
29:20
need to stop this guy cuz he's misguided
29:23
and he thinks that what he's doing is
29:24
for the betterment of all when really
29:25
he's just kind of blinded by his
29:28
well-intentioned extremism.
29:30
>> Yeah, he has this idea that if he can
29:32
get a set of these MacGuffins, he can
29:35
randomly make half of the universe
29:37
disappear, therefore alleviating a lot
29:39
of overpopulation, making sure people
29:41
have access to clean water, food, these
29:43
sorts of things.
29:43
>> So what you're saying is Thanos is
29:46
Thanos was a celestial and he did
29:48
nothing wrong?
29:48
>> No, I'm I'm saying you could probably
29:50
get really deep in that campaign before
29:51
your your party actually figured out
29:53
what was happening.
29:54
>> [laughter]
29:55
>> Wait a second.
29:56
I saw this in theaters.
29:58
>> Man, there is no version of Thanos where
30:00
he isn't a huge idiot.
30:01
>> Mhm. Mhm. Mhm.
30:03
>> That's fair. [laughter]
30:05
Like I know, let's wipe out half the
30:06
population. The population definitely
30:09
won't repopulate. That's not a thing.
30:11
>> Yeah.
30:12
>> Even
30:13
solved once and for all.
30:15
>> [laughter]
30:15
>> Yeah, gosh, the comic book villain
30:17
version of Thanos, slightly better. He
30:19
wants to wipe out half the population in
30:22
the universe to impress Death.
30:24
>> Yeah, his girlfriend Death.
30:26
>> Yeah.
30:26
>> That's complicated. Okay.
30:27
>> You know You know what Death does
30:29
instead? She dates Deadpool.
30:30
>> Marvel's weird, y'all.
30:32
>> Yeah.
30:33
>> [laughter]
30:34
>> Okay, you know what? Maybe let's not
30:35
build based our celestial campaign on
30:36
that.
30:37
>> Yeah.
30:38
>> [laughter]
30:39
>> You know, maybe not a smart idea.
30:42
So, when we talk about celestials from a
30:45
player perspective,
30:47
how can we do this interesting?
30:49
>> All right. So, the only option in
30:51
existence for playing anything adjacent
30:53
to a celestial is to summon celestial
30:56
badgers.
30:58
>> Wait, what?
30:59
>> [laughter]
31:01
>> I I'm kidding, of course.
31:03
All right. So, way back when in that way
31:06
back machine, the line of spells called
31:08
summon monster, which have existed for a
31:11
long time in D&D, would allow you to
31:13
summon creatures from a list that
31:15
improved as you got better better
31:17
versions of the spell. In third edition,
31:20
like 3X PF 1, the first level version of
31:24
the spell would let you summon a
31:27
celestial badger. Why that? Sincerely,
31:30
absolutely no idea. So, every time you
31:32
cast this spell, you pulled up the
31:34
badger stat block, you applied the
31:35
celestial template to it, you squinted
31:38
and be like, why is this badger an
31:39
angel? Why is this here? And then the
31:42
badger would come out with three attacks
31:44
and smite evil, and you had a good time.
31:47
>> That's wild. Okay, were there were there
31:49
any other crazy celestial monsters or
31:51
was it like the celestial badger and
31:52
that's it?
31:53
>> Well, there was just a celestial
31:54
template that you could apply to like
31:56
any humanoid or
31:58
>> I'm sorry. On the summon list, were
32:01
there a bunch of other celestial
32:02
creatures like celestial badger? That's
32:04
the one you want.
32:05
>> The celestial badger is just the one
32:07
that jumps out at me cuz like that is
32:08
kind of the default go to I'm a first
32:11
level wizard. This is what I'm going to
32:13
summon for some reason.
32:14
>> I I almost wonder if like is that a
32:17
callback to the Wisconsin badgers given
32:18
that the game was created [laughter]
32:20
in Wisconsin?
32:21
>> Man, I don't know. Okay, all right. I
32:24
just pulled up the SRD cuz I had to
32:26
know. There are weirder things. Okay,
32:29
celestial dog, celestial owl, celestial
32:32
giant fire beetle, which is basically
32:34
just a giant beetle that glows a little
32:36
bit, celestial porpoise for some reason,
32:39
celestial badger, and then celestial
32:41
monkey. Why any of these things?
32:43
>> Hey, D&D has miniature giant space
32:45
hamsters. I don't ask those kinds of
32:47
questions anymore.
32:48
>> [laughter]
32:50
>> Not in this day and age.
32:51
>> Yeah. So, yeah, you could throw the
32:53
celestial template on a bunch of stuff.
32:55
You could have celestial dragons. I
32:57
don't know.
32:58
It was weird.
32:59
>> Celestial chicken fries. I don't know.
33:02
>> Sure. [laughter]
33:03
Look, they have fiendish chickens. Why
33:05
not? All right. So, more seriously,
33:08
there are player-facing options for, you
33:11
know, doing things with celestials. The
33:14
Aasimar is probably like the first one
33:16
that people's minds go to. You can
33:17
basically be a human with some celestial
33:21
influence. It's the conceptual opposite
33:23
of a tiefling.
33:24
>> yeah, how is that pronounced? Is it
33:26
Aasimar or Aasimar
33:29
or Aasimar or yeah, Aasimar?
33:32
>> It's another one of those words that you
33:34
never you never know because you've only
33:36
ever seen it written down on your
33:37
character sheet maybe. And then
33:39
someone's like, what race are you? And
33:40
you're like
33:42
human. I'm human. Shut up.
33:44
>> Yeah.
33:45
Occasionally I grow wings. It's great.
33:47
>> [laughter]
33:49
>> There's all the obvious stuff. There's
33:51
divine spell casters, your clerics, your
33:53
paladins, whatever game you're playing,
33:55
the equivalent of that. Do you just
33:57
basically get power directly from a
33:59
deity? And sometimes that's all you want
34:02
is you want divine power from some
34:04
nebulous deity. Your light cleric is
34:07
there because he wants a fireball, not
34:09
because he actually cares about
34:10
religion. Who knows?
34:11
>> Yeah. Can't even tell me what deity they
34:13
worship.
34:14
>> This does bring us to an interesting
34:16
player option that I think warrants more
34:18
discussion, which is celestial warlocks.
34:22
Because that in of itself is quite a
34:24
fascinating character. I I personally
34:28
think that players and DMs should engage
34:30
more with warlock patrons because it
34:32
often just sort of like these are my
34:34
mechanics and we don't talk about my
34:35
patron. [laughter]
34:37
Which is boring, but I think with
34:39
celestials more than anything, that
34:40
really needs addressing because by
34:42
celestial you're obviously not a cleric
34:44
so you're not getting it from a god.
34:46
You're getting it from a celestial like
34:47
a planet or a solar deva. Why?
34:52
[laughter]
34:52
Like
34:53
my question is why would a celestial
34:56
give power to a warlock? Like it and it
35:00
definitely gives a different sort of
35:02
dynamic to the contract as opposed to
35:04
like something like a devil or a great
35:05
old one or an arch fay which tend to be
35:07
kind of toxic codependent relationships
35:11
with their warlock like the warlock is
35:14
getting power but then exchange their
35:16
mortal soul sort of thing or you know
35:19
some other bad trade-off that's bad for
35:21
them. So what is it that causes a
35:24
celestial to make a deal with a warlock?
35:26
For what purpose and what are the what
35:28
are the terms of that deal?
35:30
>> Yeah.
35:32
Well and and I want to I want to put a
35:33
little flavor on it like forget calling
35:35
it a warlock. What do we have? We have a
35:36
caster who's made an agreement with a
35:38
fiend to get power for the fiend and
35:41
presumably it wasn't like for a bag of
35:44
chips. It probably had something to do
35:45
with a soul. [laughter]
35:46
And and so you made the point earlier
35:47
like we're also not talking about
35:48
clerics. You're not getting your power
35:49
from a deity. You're getting the power
35:51
from a celestial.
35:51
>> Mhm.
35:52
>> So sure in five year we're going to call
35:54
that a warlock and you're going to use
35:56
the warlock mechanics but they they made
35:58
a deal with a humanoid and that humanoid
36:00
now has power that other people don't
36:03
have directly derived from this patron.
36:05
In other words I I don't want to say
36:06
there's a negative connotation with the
36:08
word warlock but I think there is kind
36:09
of an evil connotation
36:11
with the word warlock and so it's not
36:12
like the celestial made a deal with an
36:14
evil humanoid. They made a deal and they
36:16
gave power.
36:17
>> Yeah.
36:17
>> That is what you mean right Ash?
36:19
>> Yeah. And the fact and like you said
36:21
it's weird because warlocks are tend to
36:23
be looked down as evil. So why did the
36:27
celestial make a make a seemingly
36:30
unseemly deal with a person?
36:33
>> I don't I don't think we can quite say
36:35
that warlocks are associated with being
36:37
evil so much as like they're evil
36:39
tolerant at the very least. Like I I've
36:42
seen
36:42
>> that's that's fair.
36:44
>> I've seen plenty of warlocks are like,
36:46
yeah, I'll make a pact with a fiend for,
36:49
you know, for some greater good-aligned
36:51
purpose. Like
36:52
>> I mean, Will in Baldur's Gate.
36:53
>> [laughter]
36:54
>> Exactly. Yeah, like that does always
36:56
raise the question of like, okay, so
36:58
unless you were very much forced into
37:00
this, you had better options. If you are
37:03
willing to become a warlock, shop
37:05
around. See who will give you a better
37:07
deal. You probably don't have to pay
37:09
your entire immortal soul. And if you're
37:12
going to pay your entire immortal soul,
37:13
maybe send it to a celestial. That seems
37:16
like a better deal.
37:17
>> I think the tradeoff there is that, at
37:20
least what I would interpret in a normal
37:22
campaign, making a making a deal with a
37:25
with a devil is probably the easiest to
37:28
do of all the warlock patrons because
37:30
devils are always there. They're willing
37:32
to make a deal. Let's cut a deal.
37:33
Archfey are kind of, you know, flighty
37:35
and they do their own thing. Great old
37:37
ones, good luck contacting one. And
37:40
like, you know, undead, like they pretty
37:43
much have all they need. You probably
37:44
have to go dungeon diving to find a lich
37:46
who is willing to [laughter] sponsor
37:49
you. Jesus,
37:51
don't make deals with Jesus.
37:53
But yeah, celestials would probably be
37:55
the hardest because
37:58
they are very incentivized to not give
38:01
power to people who come asking for it
38:03
because usually a person who wants power
38:06
is not some someone that a celestial
38:08
wants to give power to.
38:10
>> Yeah, and I to take that one step
38:12
further, like what is the reason why the
38:15
deity that the celestial is associated
38:17
with wouldn't give you power in the form
38:20
of being a cleric or paladin, but the
38:22
celestial is like, yeah. [laughter]
38:24
Yeah, this this this is this is our
38:26
person. I I think the best answer is
38:27
like, okay, similarly to how maybe the
38:30
warlock went for the easiest thing
38:31
possible and they went and they found a
38:32
fiend to get power from, imagine a
38:34
celestial on a time crunch in a pinch is
38:36
trying to solve some problem and and the
38:39
only person next to them is Jeff the
38:41
Unclean. [laughter]
38:43
It's it's almost the the reverse
38:45
position. It's like, okay, look, I'm
38:46
willing to give you this power so we can
38:47
get out of this jam. If I get, do you
38:49
promise to be good? Are you going to be
38:50
good? Are you going to behave?
38:53
And and Jeff the Warlock was born.
38:54
>> Yeah. So I think there's a few ways you
38:57
could approach that. Yeah, you could
38:58
have it like maybe the celestial is
38:59
trying to rehabilitate a formerly bad
39:02
person. The formerly bad person wants
39:03
redemption. The celestial is like, okay,
39:05
the gods not willing to forgive you, but
39:07
I saw that what you're capable of, we
39:09
can work something out. Or maybe it's a
39:11
Tyrael situation. Renegade, he sees
39:14
potential in a mortal where the gods
39:16
have kind of been dismissive of him and
39:17
he's like, look, no, you have potential
39:21
and I want to nurture that. I mean,
39:23
having Tyrael as your celestial patriot
39:25
would be dope.
39:26
Be very cool.
39:27
>> Yeah, I'm in. I I I want to make another
39:30
another analogy to popular culture. John
39:33
Constantine.
39:34
>> Oh, yeah.
39:34
>> I I I'm not familiar. Have it Dark Horse
39:36
Comics, that's the actual where
39:37
publication for Constantine. I haven't
39:39
read it. And so for folks at home who
39:41
are huge fans, I'm sorry. All I've seen
39:43
is Keanu Reeves movie.
39:44
>> [laughter]
39:44
>> No, John Constantine's definitely a
39:46
celestial Warlock.
39:48
>> Uh well and but my understanding of it
39:50
is, say this differently, what I took
39:52
away from the movie, he can't go to
39:54
heaven for for reasons and we don't have
39:56
to get into that here, but he strictly
39:58
broke a rule that said he can't go to
40:00
heaven. And so he's basically using
40:01
these these celestial powers gifted to
40:04
him in order to try to buy his way back
40:06
into the favor of God and get into
40:08
heaven. That's that's perfect. Like
40:11
>> Yeah.
40:11
>> in in our world, this particular deity
40:14
who this person has an affinity for, you
40:16
broke a court in it. You know, I I I
40:19
don't know.
40:19
>> You you double dipped at the nacho bar.
40:22
>> No, that's it. That was the one. And you
40:24
will never make up for that, but the
40:25
celestial sees the good in you and
40:27
thinks that, you know, eventually you
40:28
can survive a buffet.
40:30
[laughter]
40:32
I like it. Let's do that. I want to play
40:34
that character now. Can I play that
40:35
character now?
40:35
>> Jeff the unclean celestial Warlock
40:38
doomed to try and buy his way back into
40:40
heaven because he double dipped at a
40:42
nacho bar. His one weakness is the sword
40:45
of the unpronounceable sword name made
40:47
of soap.
40:48
>> It's
40:48
>> canon now.
40:50
>> [laughter]
40:51
>> Look, we'll put it on a shirt right next
40:52
to the uh the Stevie's magic boots.
40:55
[laughter]
40:58
All right.
40:59
Should we talk about killing celestials?
41:01
>> Don't.
41:02
>> Yeah, after all that.
41:03
>> Yeah.
41:03
>> [laughter]
41:03
>> All right.
41:04
You you you've got your infinite warlock
41:07
power. You meet your patron. Turns out
41:09
they're a huge jerk. They double dip at
41:11
the buffet, too.
41:12
>> And you're you're judging me? You're
41:13
judging me for double dipping and I'm
41:15
just I watched you. I I got it.
41:17
Everybody here saw it.
41:19
>> [laughter]
41:20
>> You dipped, you bit, you dipped again.
41:22
Like what's that sign for? Anyway. Uh
41:25
all right.
41:25
>> It's like putting your whole mouth right
41:27
in the dip.
41:29
>> [laughter]
41:29
>> All right. So the the biggest problem I
41:31
have with celestials is they're kind of
41:33
Mary Sues. Like they they don't really
41:36
have a weakness. Like
41:39
>> Which is
41:39
>> How do you kill them?
41:40
>> Nope.
41:41
>> Like it's just hit point attrition and
41:43
hope.
41:44
>> Yeah, just be really high level, roll
41:46
really well, count on your DM to not.
41:49
>> Be good, don't be bad.
41:50
>> which is why when we say kill
41:53
celestials, I say don't because it
41:55
doesn't work.
41:56
Unless you do something like in an evil
41:58
game where whoever is your patron or
42:01
whatever gives you a secret weapon to
42:03
strip them of their divinity or
42:05
something, which can be kind of cruel
42:07
and unusual. There is something kind of
42:10
creepy and
42:11
vaguely cathartic about killing
42:13
something that's supposed to be the
42:14
embodiment of good in a rather cruel and
42:17
unusual way. So have fun with [laughter]
42:18
that.
42:20
>> Okay, so so there are a couple of
42:22
options depending on like what edition
42:24
what game you're playing. So protection
42:26
from evil has been around at least since
42:29
second edition. Like there's protection
42:31
from evil, protection from good,
42:32
protection of law from law, and
42:34
protection from chaos. And yes, those
42:36
were all completely distinct spells that
42:38
you had to both prepare and learn
42:40
separately.
42:41
>> Kill me.
42:42
>> Yeah, in in fifth edition they got
42:43
rolled into protection from evil and
42:46
good. So it's just one spell. Weirdly,
42:48
it doesn't care about alignment. It's
42:51
basically protection from things that
42:53
are extra planar. So elementals, fey,
42:57
fiends, celestials all have disadvantage
43:00
on attacks against you. So this is the
43:01
fifth edition version. I'm struggling to
43:03
remember the Pathfinder version right
43:05
now. But it's a first level spell. You
43:08
throw it on. You're suddenly very very
43:10
well protected against these creatures.
43:12
It's a fantastic buff. It also makes you
43:15
immune to mind control for some reason.
43:17
So yeah, you throw it on. Your high
43:19
level suddenly that that planetar that's
43:21
shooting arrows at you having a lot more
43:23
trouble makes it easier to kill these
43:25
things. And then okay, PF2 has alignment
43:29
damage, right? We've talked about this
43:30
before. There's good damage. There's law
43:33
damage. There's bad damage. There's evil
43:35
damage. There isn't actually bad damage.
43:37
I'm kidding. But celestials typically
43:39
have vulnerability to evil damage.
43:41
Fiends typically deal evil damage. And
43:45
then you know, the inverse fiends have
43:47
weakness to good damage. Celestials deal
43:49
good damage. So if you ever get a
43:50
celestial and a fiend in a room and have
43:52
them fight, it's going to be over real
43:53
fast. I can't tell you which one's going
43:55
to win, but like they'll go through hit
43:56
points real fast. So if you can deal
43:59
alignment damage to celestials in PF2,
44:02
that'll eat through their hit points
44:04
very very quickly. Also because
44:06
alignment exists in PF2, the most
44:08
optimal alignment is always true
44:10
neutral.
44:11
>> think they're getting rid of alignment
44:12
in the remaster though.
44:13
>> They sure are. So I'm really curious to
44:15
see what they're going to do with that.
44:17
>> [laughter]
44:18
>> So this advice is good for like eight
44:20
more months.
44:20
>> Yeah, it's Look, people will still be
44:22
playing the pre me remaster books for
44:24
probably a year or two like most of the
44:26
community. And then you know, once
44:28
there's enough cool post remaster stuff,
44:30
everybody will start moving over.
44:32
>> All right, we have a question of the
44:33
week this week. This week our question
44:34
of the week comes to us from Twitter at
44:37
great saboteur. Can you debate the
44:39
merits of a rogue paladin multiclass for
44:41
me?
44:41
>> Yes.
44:42
>> Yes.
44:42
>> Oh, did yes? Is that are we saying that
44:45
it's a good it's a good idea or that we
44:47
can do it?
44:48
>> Yeah, no, that we can debate it.
44:50
>> Yes, yes, yes.
44:51
>> All hail the Leisure Illuminati.
44:53
>> [laughter]
44:54
>> No, no, no. Let's
44:55
>> talk about it. Okay.
44:57
>> I don't know. I'm you'll have to correct
45:00
me on this, Tyler. don't know how well
45:03
those two go together cuz the problem is
45:05
is that rogue needs to have like
45:08
dexterity-based weapons in order to
45:10
sneak attack, right? Yeah, I guess it
45:12
kind of works. I think that you would
45:14
probably be I think it would probably be
45:16
better if you did warlock and just did
45:18
Eldritch Smite, but that's that's just
45:21
me. I don't know.
45:22
>> So so walk me through it. I've actually
45:23
never played a paladin or a rogue and
45:26
and so I'm only kind of superficially
45:27
like I haven't gotten in the weeds of
45:28
it. If I'm playing a paladin, especially
45:30
at early levels, I'm having fun with my
45:33
smites and I get what so many smites by
45:36
proficiency level?
45:37
>> It it's you spend spell slots.
45:39
>> You spend spell slots. Okay. All right.
45:41
So what what would you do here? You
45:42
would take would you take the dip in
45:44
rogue? Would you take the dip in
45:45
paladin?
45:46
>> It depends on what you want really.
45:48
>> I
45:49
>> So dexterity paladins can absolutely
45:51
work.
45:51
>> Yeah. I would say that you should
45:53
probably focus more on the rogue than
45:56
the paladin because the paladin most of
45:58
its stuff is going to be
46:00
weighted towards you wearing heavy armor
46:02
and heavy armor kind of defeats the
46:04
purpose of being a rogue. So maybe don't
46:06
we lean that way.
46:08
>> When you say it defeats the purpose of
46:09
being a rogue, meaning that you're not
46:10
going to be very good at sneaking.
46:11
>> Yeah.
46:12
>> Yeah. Yeah.
46:12
>> Okay. Okay. So so paladins especially in
46:15
5E were built with one very very narrow
46:18
idea of what a paladin should be. It's
46:20
very much a melee only heavy armored
46:24
front liner and then over time like
46:27
there more and more ways are emerging to
46:29
build a paladin. Like dexterity-based
46:32
paladins have really always worked. You
46:35
trade the like slightly higher AC of
46:37
heavy armor for you know better dex
46:39
saves, the ability to sneak, all those
46:41
things. And yeah like combining smite
46:44
and sneak attack can work which I think
46:47
is probably what people are looking at
46:49
here, but honestly your sneak attack
46:51
damage scaling is going to scale well
46:53
enough and be usable frequently enough
46:55
that adding divine smite to the mix
46:57
doesn't really get you anything. More
46:59
likely, you're going into paladin for
47:02
like buffs, for weapon style, for things
47:05
like that. And then if you're a paladin
47:06
dipping into rogue, you probably just
47:08
want cunning action, honestly. The
47:10
ability to move extra to disengage as a
47:13
bonus action, very powerful.
47:15
>> Okay. And then I think let's we always
47:17
like to talk about opportunity cost. If
47:19
you go for the rogue paladin versus
47:20
taking a dip somewhere else, like what
47:24
what are the things that you look at and
47:24
say I would never do that because I
47:26
would prefer, as you said, the warlock
47:28
paladin, for instance?
47:30
>> Yeah, like two levels of warlock instead
47:33
of two levels of rogue generally a
47:35
better combination.
47:36
>> Okay. And then if if my dream really is
47:38
to still like I'm going to be that melee
47:40
caster melee caster perfect. I'm going
47:42
to be that melee fighter. I'm going to
47:43
be in the mix and you're thinking well
47:45
like warlock isn't going to give me the
47:47
character concept that I want. Is there
47:49
a different class you think would be
47:50
better to take that dip in to still have
47:52
that like melee but borrowing something
47:54
from the rogue from the fighter?
47:56
>> Sorcadin.
47:56
>> Yeah.
47:57
>> Yeah.
47:57
>> Like two levels of sorcerer for font of
47:59
magic. You melt all your spell slots
48:01
down to first level so you can smite
48:03
basically every turn. Yeah, it works.
48:05
>> Or you do like five or six levels in
48:08
paladin and then do the rest in sorcerer
48:11
so you have a bunch of spell slots to
48:12
smite with. You have extra attack still
48:15
and you can twin spell hold person and
48:18
just [laughter] crit on everybody and
48:19
it's delicious. So yeah.
48:22
>> Okay. And so the trick there was I'm I
48:23
am still going to be that melee fighter.
48:25
I'm still going to do all the smiting
48:26
but the way that I'm going to do that is
48:28
I'm going to melt all up I'm I'm going
48:30
to detach all of my spell slots to
48:32
basically be able to smite all day every
48:34
day.
48:35
>> Mhm.
48:35
>> Yeah.
48:35
>> Pretty much.
48:36
>> Yeah, [laughter] okay. That makes a ton
48:37
of sense. That feels like a much more
48:39
satisfying way to use.
48:40
>> Yeah, okay.
48:41
>> Okay. So so final answer on merits of
48:44
rogue paladin like there are better
48:46
options. Adding cunning action to a
48:48
paladin can be super useful. If you're
48:51
if you have sentinel so you can like
48:52
prevent enemies from getting away from
48:55
you and all that, using cunning action
48:58
so that you can move safely to position
49:00
yourself to better make opportunity tax.
49:02
That's a great combo that a lot of
49:03
people really don't use for some reason.
49:06
Narratively, it's just kind of fun. Like
49:08
maybe you started as a rogue and you're
49:09
like, hey, you found religion, you went
49:11
straight, you became Paladin. In in 3.5
49:15
there were a couple of prestige classes
49:17
that were specifically built to be like
49:19
rogue Paladin and rogue cleric. I'm
49:23
absolutely spacing on their names. I had
49:25
it like 30 seconds ago. They were cool.
49:27
They were really bad though.
49:28
>> Yeah, I think there's um people who are
49:30
more familiar with Pathfinder 1 will
49:32
have to correct me on this, but I
49:33
believe Inquisitor was basically that.
49:35
It was a combination of Paladin and
49:37
rogue. You're basically like the
49:39
enforcement of your religion. Seek down
49:41
heretics and evildoers and smite them
49:44
while being stealthy about it.
49:46
>> Kind of, yeah. Like there there's a
49:48
little more nuance to it and they really
49:49
really liked teamwork feats for some
49:51
reason. Like when the Inquisitor came
49:53
out, Paizo was just super into teamwork
49:56
feats for whatever reason.
49:58
>> Yeah.
49:58
>> Like everything was teamwork feats for a
50:00
year or two there. The Inquisitor got a
50:01
lot of that. But yeah, they they're a
50:03
cool class if you want a if you want a
50:06
Paladin rogue feel and you're playing PF
50:08
1, yeah. And then if you're playing PF
50:10
2, I don't know, maybe we'll get
50:11
Inquisitor someday. We'll see.
50:13
>> All hail the Legion Illuminati. If
50:15
you've enjoyed the show, please rate and
50:16
review us on Apple Podcast and rate us
50:18
on Spotify or your favorite podcast app.
50:20
It's a quick free way to support the
50:22
podcast and helps us to reach new
50:23
listeners. You'll find links in the show
50:25
notes. You'll find affiliate links for
50:26
source books and other materials link in
50:28
the show notes as well as on rpgbot.net.
50:30
Following these links helps us to make
50:32
this show happen every week. If your
50:34
question should be the question of the
50:35
week next week, please email podcast at
50:37
rpgbot.net or message us on Twitter at
50:40
rpg b o t d o t n e [music] t. Please
50:43
also consider supporting us on Patreon
50:44
where you'll find ad-free podcast
50:46
episodes, early access to
50:47
rpgbot.content, polls for future
50:49
content, and access to the rpgbot
50:51
Discord. [music]
50:52
You'll find us at patreon.com/rpgbot.
50:56
>> Shoot, I don't have any funny jokes this
50:57
[music] time.
50:58
What do I do?
50:59
>> And I love a rainy night. I love
51:04
>> [laughter]
51:05
>> Where did that come from?
51:06
>> No, I'm just I'm just thinking about
51:07
what the the art that somebody's going
51:09
to do for Jeff the Unwashed.
51:11
>> Oh, yeah. [laughter]
51:12
That's going to be great.
51:13
>> Someday we're going we're going to pay a
51:14
person to do that someday and that's
51:16
going to be weird.
51:17
>> No.
51:18
>> He keeps changing his name. Jeff the
51:20
Jeff the Dark, Jeff the Unclean, Jeff
51:21
the Unwashed. He's got a lot of
51:24
monikers.
51:24
>> by he goes by many names. There's one
51:28
you can't deny. His name's Jeffrey.
51:30
>> He broke his oath, but he found it again
51:31
and became Jeff the Immaculate.
51:34
>> [laughter]
51:35
>> Did he find it in the shower?
51:36
>> Yes.
51:38
He finally took a shower.
Games

