Up next in 10
Ridley Scott's Alien and James Cameron's Aliens are two of the greatest sci-fi movies ever made. When it was announced that Ridley Scott would be returning to deliver a trilogy of Alien Prequel films, fans were both excited and cautious. After Prometheus and Alien Covenant were box office disappointments, and with the Disney acquisition of Fox, it looked like the final installment in Ridley Scott's Alien Prequels would never see the light of day. Now that Alien Romulus is racing towards opening day, can Disney reclaim the glory once cemented in the Alien franchise?
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
When it was announced that Ridley Scott would finally be returning to the Alien franchise
0:10
fans lost their minds in anticipation. However, the realities of what was eventually made proved to be a bit more divisive
0:17
With two films of a proposed trilogy being produced before bottoming out
0:21
this begs the question, what exactly killed the Alien prequel trilogy? No one ever asked the obvious question
0:27
who would make such a creature as an alien and why would they design it released in 1979 ridley
0:34
scott's iconic sci-fi horror film alien turned the genre on its head this truckers in space film is
0:40
looked back on as a massive achievement originally designed to be a low-budget exploitation film the
0:45
finished product is better than anyone could have hoped for when scott and co-screenwriter dan
0:50
obannon brought some of the best artists and designers in the industry on board the project
0:54
it quickly evolved into something else. And audiences responded in kind. The film made $118 million opening weekend
1:02
which was an almost unprecedented level of success. Drove up and I parked somewhere and I got out
1:08
And so this huge line of people went down the block and around the block
1:13
And I said, is that for Alien? The success of Alien would launch a franchise
1:17
of three direct sequels, two Alien vs. Predator spinoff films, and countless toys, video games, and comic books
1:23
and so by the mid-2000s, the franchise had entered a dormant period
1:27
So inevitably, the talk of more alien films resurfaced. Alien 5, AVP3, and a few other would-be projects were discussed before the powers-that-be
1:36
landed on exploring the backstory of the space jockey in a prequel to the original film
1:42
I'll only do another science fiction if I've got a really good script. So it really, finally, it's about the story
1:48
It's all about the story. Scott, having been brought on as a producer, initially selected Carl Eric Rinch to guide the reinvestigation
1:54
of the xenomorph. Fox was not pleased with this decision. They gave him an ultimatum
1:59
Either he directed or the project was dead. Scott chose to return to the director's chair
2:03
From there, he brought in Doctor Strange and passenger screen writer John Spates to write a draft on what was at the time called Alien Engineers This script featured many of the elements that ended up in the finished film David the space jockey actually being humanoid and a cast of scientists going to a planet with a crashed alien ship on it
2:20
However, at the end of the day, this version was much more of a standard prequel to Alien
2:25
During the development process, Scott changed his mind and decided that the project should be more
2:29
of a standalone story, not as closely tied to the existing Alien franchise
2:33
This is when Lost co-creator Damon Lindelof was hired to redevelop the project
2:38
with a bit more of an avant-garde take on franchise building. Tell a story about the origins of life within the alien world
2:45
but don't actually feature the titular alien. This was a risky and lofty goal, maybe too lofty
2:50
There's one question no one asked in all four movies, much to my amazement and surprise
2:56
No one said, who's the big guy in the sea that became known as the space jockey
3:03
In the finished film, we follow a crew of deep space explorers who discover a star map and decide to track it to the ends of space
3:10
hoping to discover life outside of our own. However, what they do uncover is a nightmare beyond their wildest imagination
3:17
The film deals with themes of resentment towards a creator, the inability of humanity to understand our purpose
3:22
and the natural evolution of species being a dangerous and threatening process
3:27
If these things made us, then surely they could save us. While some viewers found the meditation of the cyclical nature of life and death a compelling
3:37
backdrop for a film, many walked away with questions about the incongruity of scenes
3:41
or the basic logic of characters. Take, for instance, how this biologist guy is freaked
3:46
out at the idea of alien life one moment, and then tries to make friends with a space snake
3:56
the next. Hey, baby. Or how David is instructed by Whalen through his dreams to try harder
4:07
And he interprets that as choosing to expose Holloway to the black ooze
4:11
Or even just the simple question of why was Guy Pearce in old man makeup the whole time
4:15
Are there literal answers to all these questions? Yes. Most of them revolving around deleted scenes that were cut from the finished runtime
4:23
But that not the point really It all boils down to the fact that the film is a flawed masterpiece If you squint you can see what Scott was going for An ambitious epic a sweeping science fiction tale created utilizing the scaffolding of
4:36
an existing franchise, but completely reimagining it from the ground up. Regrettably, Scott's reach exceeded his grasp
4:43
The film was not received with the universal praise Fox was hoping for. While it was a financial success, pulling in $403 million, it didn't quite cement itself
4:52
as a cultural touchstone. If you created me, who created you? The question of the ages
5:00
Scott initially said that the Prometheus sequel would follow David and Shaw in their attempt to
5:05
reach the engineer homeworld, yet it became clear fairly quickly that Fox was going to make Scott
5:10
recalibrate some things, if they were going to move forward. How? By bringing back the xenomorph
5:15
Either kill them outright or use them as incubators to spawn a hybrid form
5:19
Initially titled Alien Paradise Lost, the sequel to Prometheus was announced on August 1st
5:27
2012. At that point, both Fassbender and Noomi Rapace were said to be reprising their roles
5:32
However, when the eventual sequel did manifest, now titled Alien Covenant, it had been significantly altered
5:38
Shaw didn't die in the crash. No. What did you do to her? Exactly what I'm going to do to you
5:45
Gone was the Shaw and David seeking the true nature of the Engineer's plotline
5:48
and instead we follow a group of deep space settlers who have encountered a distress beacon
5:53
and become sucked up into David's machinations as a mad scientist tinkering with the new ways
5:58
of creating life on the engineer's former home world. It's almost a sci-fi version of Apocalypse
6:04
Now, but with two Fassbenders. You're meant to be dead. There have been a few updates since your day
6:12
Covenant's deviation from the threads of Prometheus feels like something of a mixed bag
6:17
You can feel in the film that Scott wants to make a movie that evolves the themes of a creation
6:21
destroying its creator, and Fox wants a movie where a xenomorph hunts people. Tragically
6:27
Covenant's mix of schlocky kills and David as a Frankenstein-esque doctor didn't exactly work out
6:32
all that well The film pulled in roughly million worldwide not exactly a resounding endorsement that would have silenced Scott internal critics at Fox The man ostensibly made a bootleg sequel to his own movie in order to get the series to continue and that wasn enough to appease fans and critics
6:48
Look on my works, ye mighty, in despair. But even so, he apparently had some internal support at Fox
6:57
with then-CEO Stacey Snyder saying in September of 2017 that Covenant was a disappointment
7:02
but that she had faith in Scott's vision for the franchise. In October of that same year, Scott said that the third film will focus more on the androids and AI
7:11
The AI might create as a leader if he finds himself onto a new planet
7:18
And from that, we had actually quite a big layout for the next one, for Covenant 2, Covenant 2, whatever we want to do
7:25
It's not quite clear how far into the development process this project got, because Scott also said
7:30
There's a platform for what we're doing right now. It'll be Prometheus, Covenant 1, Covenant 2
7:35
Then we'll probably come into the back end of Alien 1. And that's already kind of worked out
7:40
Covenant 2 is already being written. John Logan. Further leaks detailed that the third prequel film would take place on LV-426
7:48
the location of the original film, and followed David going up against a group of engineers
7:52
who are out for revenge over his murderous actions on Planet 4
7:56
Ultimately, this would not come to be. After Fox was sold to Disney, that pretty much closed the books on Scott's prequel films
8:03
Disney just felt that it was a cleaner break to not continue down the path that Scott had established
8:07
instead opting for an alien TV show and Alien Romulus. Was that the safer bet
8:12
Yes, definitely. Was it the less creatively interesting bet? Also yes. I thought Alien needed a really fresh view
8:20
And what I liked was the fact that he cast such young people. So that was a really valuable asset
8:25
Look, do Prometheus and Covenant have rough patches and, frankly, dumb elements grafted onto them
8:30
Absolutely. But the fact that both of these movies are obviously deeply personal for Scott makes them endlessly fascinating
8:37
There's Scott trying to make sense of the incomprehensible, and ironically, also becoming something of an incomprehensible mess themselves
8:44
And Disney? They didn't get that. They just saw twin-genre retreads that both underperformed at the box office
8:50
Thus, the Alien prequel trilogy was killed. which, when considering how this trilogy panned out, feels appropriate
#Movies
#Science Fiction & Fantasy Films