Up next in 10
For decades, sitcom dads followed a very familiar formula. They were clueless. Immature. Often the punchline of the joke. From the bumbling father archetype of Homer Simpson to the emotionally distant patriarch in Red Foreman, TV had a very specific idea of what a “funny dad” looked like.
And then came Modern Family's Phil Dunphy. He was something completely different. Instead of making the father figure the butt of every joke, Modern Family made him the heart of the show. At a time when sitcoms relied on cynicism and sarcasm, Phil Dunphy stood out by being genuinely kind, without ever losing what made him funny. And in doing so, he changed what audiences expect from sitcom dads forever.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
If you get pulled over for speeding, tell the policeman your spouse has diarrhea
0:09
Philososophy. This is Phil Dunphy. Corny, embarrassing, hyperactively optimistic, and honestly, just the kind of warm-hearted
0:16
super dad we all deserve. Clive Bixby's alter ego is more than your cliched, goofy dad sporting a beautiful wife
0:23
And even though Phil Dunphy was cut from the same cloth as those disgruntled father figures
0:27
of yesteryear, Modern Family's most empathetic patriarch challenges every sitcom stereotype. I'm gonna have to take the picture down when I repaint the wall anyhow
0:37
Kill me now. What? Don't know how I got so lucky. When Modern Family debuted in the fall of 2009, sitcom fans had every reason to expect
0:47
something special. Created by the former producers of boundary-pushing TV comedies Just Shoot Me and Frasier, the
0:53
ABC series quickly sparked interest with its unique perspective on family life
0:57
Focused on the inner worlds of three extremely different households, the Modern Family pilot felt like the perfect marriage
1:03
between the mockumentary shooting styles of The Office and the classic household dynamics of Roseanne or Everybody Loves Raymond
1:10
Changing the shape of an entire genre is no simple feat, but by normalizing every variety of relationship
1:16
and, most importantly, making them absolutely hilarious, Modern Family disarmed even the most jaded fans of TV comedy
1:23
And even though it was easy to love any of the central characters, it was the first appearance of one Phil Dunphy
1:29
Let me meet this player. Phil Dunphy, yo. That immediately caught our attention
1:34
because unlike the TV dads we grew up with, Phil simply cannot be categorized by cliches
1:40
Honey, do you have anything to say to your daughter about her skirt? Sorry. Oh yeah, that looks really cute, sweetheart
1:46
Thanks. Throughout the history of sitcoms, most on-screen fathers are an amalgamation of stereotypes
1:51
and generational references, Typically slotting into one of the two specific categories, TV dads are essentially templates that can appeal to the widest audience
2:01
Many sitcom favorites fall into the goofy dad mold those clueless lovable and pretty basic guys who somehow managed to marry someone way out of their league These TV dads exist to offer fatherly comedic relief
2:12
from time to time, but the overbearing father figure category is perhaps even more common
2:18
Blurring the line between super serious and downright neglectful, these TV dads usually have rocky relationships
2:23
with their spouse or kids. And while some sitcom stars like Tim, the Tool Man Taylor, and Alan Matthews
2:28
were able to blur the line between goofy dads and stern fathers, it would take a modern man to break both molds. Although Phil Dunphy was the
2:36
stereotypical breadwinner throughout the first several seasons of Modern Family, his outlook on
2:41
life is anything but traditional. Because as a father first and foremost, Phil uses his loose
2:45
work schedule to maintain a constant presence in his kids' lives. But with all the physical intensity
2:50
and eyebrow action of a dedicated Dracula performance, Phil Dunphy doesn't even look
2:55
like your average TV dad. Paired with a sincere portrayal of a people-pleaser with an overactive
3:00
penchant for puns, and you have the perfect recipe for the most oddly endearing guy on television
3:06
Every realtor is just a ninja and a blazer. The average burglar breaks in and leaves clues
3:13
everywhere, but not me. I'm completely clueless. Modern Family took great pains to develop the
3:18
Dunphyverse as a showcase for family comedy. In terms of what actually separates Phil from the
3:24
rest of the dads, the magic is in the details. Like any member of a well-rounded comedy cast
3:29
Phil Dunphy carries his share of faults and failures. A little too prideful in his line of work
3:34
Sure. A married man who still loves the ladies? Maybe so. Willing to obliterate his own son at sports
3:40
Absolutely. But unlike so many classic rough and tumble TV dads, Phil Dunphy is all hard and no harsh
3:46
Can't do this. The point is you're scared. I think you've learned your lesson. Wow
3:51
Because when it comes to his job, Phil Dunphy just wants to find you your dream home
3:55
as a sales friend. Even though his fascination with his mother-in-law can get a little frisky, Phil the Thrill genuinely
4:01
respects women in ways sitcom dads aren't usually known for. And in Dispensing Parental Guidance, Dunphy's Phil-losophy
4:08
always has his family best interests in mind Open and willing to listen he often serves as a springboard for the emotions of those around him Even Jay his eternally cranky father couldn help but open up to Phil in a time of great need
4:22
More concerned about being pals with his kids than most stoic father figures
4:26
Phil Dunphy dispenses pun-filled affirmations to the family rather than force-feeding them life lessons
4:31
Just as willing to hype up his lovely wife when she's down as he is to encourage his kids when they're struggling
4:36
Phil comes across as the world's most hilarious golden retriever, and when he tries to chase Haley down to let her know how proud he really is of her
4:43
there wasn't a dry eye in the house. Even when the norms of fatherhood are being challenged in wild ways
4:48
Phil always manages to come through looking like a stand-up guy. Gloria tells me you had a real good time
4:54
Not really. No, I didn't. God, I love your daughter. Oh, I should come by and kiss that step. Fix that step
5:00
Even when Claire became a powerful businesswoman, Phil took his new station as a quote-unquote trophy wife with Grace
5:05
And after staking his own claim in the parking lot business, Phil Dunphy made us believe in his ability to evolve
5:12
But behind every exceptionally written TV character, there must be a sitcom star willing to go that extra mile
5:17
And when it came time to cast Phil Dunphy, the Modern Family showrunners knew exactly who to call
5:22
Although actor Ty Burrell had plenty of experience on television, his previous sitcoms and guest roles hadn't fully connected with viewers
5:29
For many, Burrell's intense looks and commanding presence seemed more suited for his sleazy survivor character
5:35
in Zack Snyder's Dawn of the Dead. According to Burrell himself, ABC executives weren't sold on his first audition
5:40
I really flopped the first test, the actor said, and recalled the brutal note the studio had for him
5:45
He's not funny, and some people still feel that way. Eventually, Burrell and the showrunners
5:50
proved that they had their fill, and before long, he joined the ranks among the other Dunfees
5:54
Once the actor was turned loose on set, he dialed Modern Family's comedy up to Phil Levin
5:59
I really enjoy improvising, Burrell reported. I noticed that off whatever silliness I end up spitting out of my mouth
6:04
it starts a really fun collaboration. Through a deadly combination of Burrell's comedy chops
6:09
and the extraordinary writing in Modern Family, Phil Dunphy came into our lives as a fully realized reflection of fatherhood
6:16
Stop now We can only screw it up from here Please you on the hands of the master I think I know how to pick up a 14 girl for you Incapable of being ironic and according to Claire impossible to lie to
6:27
Phil doesn't carry the typical macho vibes of male characters on television
6:32
From Mitch and Cam's willingness to get down and dirty to protect their family
6:35
to Jay's aged and refined take on machismo, Phil is a man apart even on his own show
6:41
While his affable approach to life is admirable, it's always funny to see his inherent chillness blow up in his face
6:47
And on the rare occasion that Phil is forced to get physical, his actual prowess is somehow just as hilarious
6:53
Even though Phil displays plenty of classic goofy dad energy, Modern Family stands apart from most sitcom norms
7:00
Most goofy dad types can't afford to lose any laughs and therefore rarely have a chance to get personal outside of so-called very special episodes
7:08
But for Phil, even the most outlandish behavior can turn into a truly emotional moment
7:13
Because the goofy dad types basically never have a serious impact, their storylines often fail to meet the challenges of real life
7:20
And though it's true that nobody goes to sitcoms for reality-based programming
7:24
there was clearly an untapped market for hilarious, supportive fathers. No dad wants to have this talk with his son, but you're just not eating enough hot dogs
7:33
While Dan Conner most definitely slots into the goofy dad role when necessary
7:37
his ability to get serious is perhaps the closest precursor to Phil Dunphy
7:42
Despite the obvious differences, both Dan and Phil transcend societal norms of parenthood to
7:47
offer their kids a better life. But when it comes down to goofy TV dads and stern sitcom father
7:52
figures, few can muster those earnest qualities necessary for emotional maturity. From historically
7:58
happy Danny Tanner to the legendary Uncle Phil, even the most kind-hearted father figures are just
8:04
a tad too reserved to hit home. Whether we're talking about the harsh love of Grounded for Life
8:09
or the surrealism of Bryan Cranston's Hal, it's tough to be as well-rounded as Phil Dunphy
8:14
a character that exceeds all expectations. Phil isn't just wacky, hilarious, or wise
8:19
He's a nice guy and a really good dad. And from the very beginning up until its stirring finale
8:25
he made us all wish we had been born a Dunphy