Up next in 10
Not that long ago, Pixar stood at the very top of the animation world. With timeless classics like Toy Story, Monsters Inc., The Incredibles, and Ratatouille, the studio wasn’t just making hits, they were redefining what 3D animation could be. But over the last decade, Pixar’s track record has been filled with missteps, disappointments, and box office flops. Each new release seems to arrive with less excitement, less cultural impact, and far fewer fans rallying behind it.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
What I say is true. Anyone can cook, but only the fearless can be great
0:07
Pure poetry. For almost two decades, Pixar wasn't just a movie studio. It was a cultural event
0:14
When you saw that bouncing lamp logo before a film, it didn't matter what it was called
0:18
You just knew it was going to be good. Absolute classics like Toy Story, Monsters, Inc., The Incredibles, Finding Nemo, WALL-E, or Up
0:26
Every single release felt like a new chapter in a golden age of animation
0:30
one that balanced heart, humor, and human emotion in a way nobody else could touch
0:35
But now? The lamp still hops, the logo still shines, but when a new Pixar movie drops
0:41
audiences are left wondering, where did the magic go? How are you doing that
0:45
I don't know. Where are you doing dumb stuff? One of Pixar's earliest successes came in 1986 with Luxo Jr
0:52
The short featured a pair of animated desk lamps and was a pioneering work in CGI animation
0:57
It demonstrated the emotional depth and expressiveness that could be achieved using computer graphics
1:03
Following their success, Pixar continued to produce short films. Red's Dream and Tin Toy each showed their knack for attaching emotional impact and empathy to everyday objects
1:13
Pixar eventually entered into a partnership with Walt Disney Pictures, and this collaboration led to the development of Toy Story, Pixar's first feature-length film
1:21
You are a toy! You are a child's plaything! You are a sad, strange little man
1:31
It was also the world's first fully computer animated film, and instantly, Pixar became the future
1:37
Toy Story wasn't just groundbreaking because it was CGI. It was groundbreaking because it had soul
1:42
These were toys that questioned purpose, identity, and mortality, all wrapped in a buddy comedy for kids
1:48
It made $400 million worldwide, but more importantly, it proved Pixar could do what no other studio could, make movies that spoke to both adults and children at the same time
2:04
And over the next 15 years they didn just repeat that success They built an empire out of it
2:11
They became a genre unto themselves. From 1995 to 2010, Pixar was untouchable
2:17
Every movie was an event, a promise that you were about to cry, laugh, and then cry again
2:22
These weren't just good animated movies. They were modern classics, defining moments for millions of children that would help fundamentally shape their lives because of the lessons they taught about morality and love
2:33
For performing above and beyond the call of duty, I would like to award you the highest honor I can bestow, the Ellie Badge
2:45
And the studio wasn't afraid to take risks. They made a movie about a French rat who wants to be a chef, a silent sci-fi love story between robots
2:53
an opening montage about the death of a spouse that plays out like a short film
2:58
Pixar was giving kids the first existential crisis of their lives, and parents a chance to reckon with their own
3:04
By 2010, Pixar wasn't just the best animated studio in the world, they were the most consistent studio in Hollywood
3:10
But then, things started to change. It's hard to pinpoint the exact moment Pixar started to stumble
3:15
but most people would agree it begins right after Toy Story 3
3:19
But the thing that makes Woody special is he'll never give up on you
3:25
Ever. That film felt like a perfect ending, both for the characters and for the studio's first era
3:31
And then came Cars 2. Released in 2011, Cars 2 marked Pixar's first real critical failure
3:37
And the reason was obvious. It wasn't trying to be meaningful. It was trying to sell toys
3:42
Gone were the complex emotional arcs and timeless storytelling. Instead, audiences got a spy parody centered on Mater
3:49
The film still made money, but it felt like a turning point, like Pixar had finally learned
3:53
the wrong lesson from its own success. I don't want to hear none of this, sir, business
3:57
By the way, have y'all met each other? McQueen, McQueen, McQueen, McQueen, McMissle, McMissle, McQueen, McQueen, McMissle
4:04
Between 2011 and 2019 Pixar released six sequels Cars 2 Monsters University Finding Dory Incredibles 2 Toy Story 4 and Cars 3 The Pixar genre once synonymous with originality
4:18
became tied to its own nostalgia, and audiences could feel it. What changes are you going to make to get McQueen back on top
4:25
Will McQueen try new training methods? Is he prepared to retire? Guys, let's not overreact. It's just a slump
4:31
If Pixar's golden age ended with Toy Story 3, their identity crisis began with The Good Dinosaur
4:36
Released in 2015, the same year as Inside Out, The Good Dinosaur wasn't bad, exactly
4:41
but it felt generic, a movie that could have come from any animation studio
4:46
And that was a problem, especially because Pixar had built its empire off standing apart from the rest of the industry
4:52
While Inside Out, that same year, reminded everyone what Pixar was capable of
4:56
it also unintentionally highlighted how inconsistent the studio had become. I'm sorry, something's wrong with me
5:03
It's like I'm having a breakdown. You're not having a breakdown. It's stress
5:07
From 2016 onward, Pixar became just another studio making films. Only 2017's Coco brought back the old feeling of being a capital M moment for audiences
5:17
Movies like Luca, Soul, and Turning Red skipped theaters entirely, debuting directly on Disney+
5:23
Audiences started to see Pixar movies not as events, but as content
5:28
What's wrong with you, stupid-o? When Pixar finally did return to theaters with Lightyear in 2022, the result was a disaster
5:40
Marketed as a big return to form, Lightyear was supposed to reignite interest in one of
5:44
Pixar's most beloved franchises. Instead, it confused audiences who couldn't figure out what
5:49
it even was. A reboot? A spinoff? A meta-prequel? Whatever it was, it didn't work. The film cost
5:56
$200 million and flopped, barely making back its budget while Toy Story 4 made over a billion dollars just three years earlier
6:04
It did not go as planned. The mission was unsuccessful? Affirmative. Oh, no
6:09
But there something deeper happening here too For years Pixar strength came from how it spoke to adults through children stories Up wasn really about adventure it was about grief The Incredibles wasn just some superhero romp
6:22
it was a statement about the importance of family and a support system
6:25
Toy Story, the first three at least, were never about toys, they were about growing up and letting go
6:31
Pixar mastered the art of hiding profound existential themes inside colorful, family-friendly packages
6:36
But in recent years, that balance seems to have tilted too far toward just for kids
6:41
Films like Onward and Elemental have their moments, but their themes feel simplified
6:46
They're not bad movies, they're just fine. And fine is not what built Pixar's reputation
6:51
The studio that once pioneered the look of modern animation now feels like it's chasing its own formula
6:57
That formula just isn't connecting the way it used to. The world is often unkind to new talent, new creations
7:04
than you needs friends. At one point, Pixar's creative process was almost mythic
7:10
They famously had something called the Brain Trust, a group of veteran directors and storytellers
7:15
who gave unfiltered feedback on every project. This was the secret sauce
7:20
But as Pixar grew, and as many of those original creatives left
7:24
that brain trust dynamic started to fall apart. Instead of a tight-knit creative circle
7:28
Pixar became a sprawling corporate machine under Disney's watchful eye. And when you have to deliver one film every year, plus short-form content, plus spinoffs for Disney+
7:38
pressure to innovate gets replaced by the pressure to produce. I know things have changed. We've got to go back
7:44
There was a time when Pixar's logo was more than a marketing symbol. It meant trust. It meant that
7:49
no matter what the premise was, a rat chef, a trash robot, a monster in a closet, you were about
7:55
to see something deeply human. Today, that trust is fractured. Pixar has become the studio that
8:01
might release something great, but might also release something you'll forget in a week. The
8:05
consistency just doesn't exist anymore. In its golden age, Pixar changed the way we think about
8:10
animated movies, maybe even movies period. But even the brightest light can fade when it's overused
8:16
And while that lamp still hops, it's not shining quite like it used to