Up next in 10
For years, the Mystery Box formula has been blamed for some of TV’s most frustrating finales — shows that pile on endless questions but rarely deliver satisfying answers. So when Ben Stiller’s Severance returned for Season 2, fans wondered: would it fall into the same trap, or finally break the cycle?
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Am I dead? No. This isn't like hell or something? No. Then why can't I leave? Well, you did leave
0:06
just now, but you came back. I did not. You did. When Severance first appeared on Apple Plus
0:12
no one could have predicted where the series would lead us. With its jarring blend of workplace
0:16
comedy, sci-fi thrillers, and the high strangeness of David Lynch, the show quickly garnered hordes
0:21
of cautiously optimistic viewers. Steeped in secrets, weird by design, and utterly confusing
0:27
at times, the innies of Lumen Industries seemed at risk of falling into the dreaded mystery box
0:33
I can sense that the questions made you feel afraid or disoriented
0:37
Well, the good news is, you're at an orientation. Seemingly the source for all our most unsatisfying TV finales, the mystery box formula has long
0:47
been debated amongst general audiences. And with Severance initially serving more questions than answers, it appeared as though
0:54
this retro-futurist drama might disappoint. But by the time season two started streaming, our burning questions were answered, and as
1:01
the showrunners took us directly to Cold Harbor, it became clear that these winding halls had
1:07
been fully mapped out. While it should be a given that mystery-driven plots would see some semblance of resolution
1:13
especially during the duration of a long-running series, that's just not always the case
1:17
Because ever since the great mystery box takeover of the 2000s, our televisions haven't quite
1:23
been the same. Guys. Back in 2007, director J.J. Abrams delivered a TED Talk that gave a name to the changing
1:32
landscape of television. Then, serving as the showrunner for the groundbreaking series Lost
1:37
Abrams coined his brand of perpetual riddles as the mystery box. Named after an unopened grab bag
1:43
from a magic shop, the director explained that mystery is the catalyst for imagination
1:48
For some reason, I haven't opened this box. And I felt like there was a key to this somehow
1:52
I started to think that maybe there are times when mystery is more important than knowledge
1:56
So I started thinking about loss and stuff that we do and I realized oh my god mystery boxes are everywhere in what I do While Abram secrecy certainly cashed in on audience appeal throughout the early aughts the very concept of the mystery box eventually soured on culture at large
2:11
From Heroes to Westworld, these overtly mysterious shows kept asking questions without delivering satisfying answers
2:18
And as modern puzzlers such as Yellow Jackets have continued the legacy of inconclusive climaxes
2:24
many viewers have simply turned their backs on the mystery box idea
2:27
But unlike many other mysterious television scripts that preceded it, Severance debuted with a game plan
2:33
As the mind-wiped in-ease of Lumen serves some greater unknown, audiences at first experienced a barrage of questions throughout those early episodes
2:41
Whether it's the scrambled messages on immaculate computer monitors, the true meaning of the break room, or the sinister machinations of Harmony Cobell, Severance Season 1 kept everyone guessing
2:51
But rather than obsessing over the greater plots and purpose, most viewers were instead taken over by the sheer force of creativity on display
3:00
Did you grow me as food and that's why I have no memories? Do you think we grew a full human, gave you consciousness
3:08
I don't know. Did your nails? I don't know. I don't know you. No, you're not livestock. Good Lord
3:13
But most importantly, unlike the cast-off code sequences and ambiguous smoke monsters of Lost
3:19
Severance knows that the devil is in the details. From keyboards without escape keys, plenty of goat-based Easter eggs, and increasingly outlandish additions to the Lumen lore, Severance goes to great lengths to keep us invested in its world-building
3:32
And, to the relief of many, those small riddles expose greater truths rather than serving as mystery box MacGuffins
3:39
When season one came to its world-shaking conclusion, many viewers were stunned
3:43
Having shattered many of Lumen's rules and after answering an abundance of questions, you might assume the series had few secrets left to reveal
3:51
But even as the innies broke out of Lumen and into the real world
3:55
Severance still managed to heighten the mystery. We're prisoners! She alive Severance willingness to explain itself while simultaneously deepening the lore is a balance so few shows can ever achieve Twin Peaks perhaps the grandfather of mystery box television
4:14
notoriously lost that balance after its very first season. Originally a cultural phenomenon
4:20
the cable show spilled one too many secrets early on in its run and completely lost its relevance
4:25
as a result. While Twin Peaks certainly got the recognition it deserves in later years
4:29
the shadow of Laura Palmer's poorly planned mystery still looms large. Dodging the mistakes of its forefathers, Severance Season 2 defied the sophomore slump
4:43
and met its high expectations head on. Taking place five months after the shocking events of
4:47
Season 1's finale, the innies are once again deposited through the Lumen elevator and into
4:52
a sci-fi corporate hell. The innies are each told that their outies have relinquished them back into
4:58
Lumen's grip, after some new additions to a proper work-life balance, of course
5:02
I don't want to be your jailer. By end of day, each of you will choose whether you want to remain here
5:07
Not your outies, but you. Unconvinced of the new bright and shiny demeanor of their overseers, the innies once again attempt
5:15
to explore the complex office building and uncover its many secrets. And as we are introduced to new
5:20
environments and characters like the Goat Room and the Goat Lady, we are given a sense of wonder
5:25
and awe, rather than a cloying feeling that we won't get any answers. Because we have already
5:30
been given the reasoning behind so many secrets, we have faith that all this goat stuff will pay
5:35
off. In addition to ramping up the strangeness at Lumen with religious sermons and bizarre rituals
5:40
the audience also experiences the satisfaction of knowing the secrets of the innies. Because we
5:45
understand who they are as outies, our suspense is maintained in the eyes of their co-workers
5:51
friends, and lovers. And unlike the overly dramatic flashback sequences of other mystery box shows
5:56
these outer lives have purpose and meaning as it relates to the plot. This facet is perhaps
6:01
no better examined than in the season two finale Cold Harbor, in which the outie and inie version
6:07
of lead Lumen employee Mark S come face to face Using a video camera the two Marks take turns explaining their situations to each other in a series of micro
6:17
As the Innie Mark explains his life at Lumen and as Audi Mark pleads his case for help
6:22
all of our greater theories and questions about the series come to a head
6:25
When the conversation eventually breaks down in anger and confusion, we feel the pain from both sides
6:31
and all the mysteries we've pondered drift away. We are in this together
6:36
can't you just trust me? No. These choices make the audience feel like we have not been led astray
6:43
and that the creative vision behind these mysteries has a plan to exceed our expectations
6:48
When the bare bones of the plot are finally laid out before our very eyes
6:52
we can actually look back on all the hints and secrets with appreciation
6:56
Because when it comes to most mystery box television, few shows ever look beyond immediate gratification
7:01
These choices make the audience feel like we have not been led astray
7:05
and that the creative vision behind these mysteries has a plan to exceed our expectations
7:10
If it's not real, then what are you doing here, Jack? Why did you come back? Why do you find it so hard to believe
7:15
Why do you find it so easy? It's never been easy! In fact, in that now infamous TED Talk
7:20
J.J. Abrams all but admits that the mystery box does not come with an instruction manual
7:24
or even a basic outline. In the creation of Lost, we had very little time to do
7:28
We had 11 and a half weeks to write it, cast it, crew it, shoot it, cut it, post it
7:33
turn it into our pilot. that sense of possibility, what could this thing be? There was no time to develop it
7:38
Fortunately for fans of Severance, the season two finale offered both a conclusive mic drop
7:42
and an entirely new kind of cliffhanger. After leading us through those brightly lit lumen halls
7:48
and into the darkest depths of its underbelly, we can have faith that Severance will go the distance
7:53
And by escaping the trappings of mystery box television at every turn thus far
7:57
because whether we're hanging with Harmony Cobell and her twisted kin, or trying to work out why exactly a child
8:03
is running the floor. Why are you a child? Because of when I was born
8:08
The show searches for that rare balance between secrecy and truth. Fortunately for us
8:13
that's a mystery Severance has already solved