Misconceptions about Getting Sick - mental_floss on YouTube (Ep. 11)
323 views
Apr 3, 2025
A weekly show where we debunk common misconceptions. This week, Elliott discusses some misconceptions about getting sick.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Hi, I'm Elliot, and this is Mental Floss on YouTube
0:03
Today, I'm going to talk to you about some misconceptions about getting sick
0:15
Misconception number one, vitamin C can prevent or treat colds. In 2007, researchers compared 29 studies containing a total of 11,306 subjects
0:25
to determine whether vitamin C was an effective way to prevent the common cold
0:29
All of the trials involved subjects who took more than 0.2 grams of vitamin C daily
0:35
as well as comparisons with subjects who took placebos. They found that vitamin C did not reduce
0:39
the incidence of common colds, though it's possible that the vitamin may have made the colds last less long
0:45
So drink your orange juice, or don't. Misconception number two, you can sweat a cold out
0:50
Some believe that when you catch a cold, the way to cure it is by wrapping yourself up in blankets
0:54
so you can sweat the germs out of your body. That's not true. As for whether you should exercise
0:58
When you have a cold, doctors actually have mixed opinions. It probably won't cure you, but if you're up for it, keep the exercise moderate and you should be just fine
1:06
Or you can do what I do and get your exercise in by whining constantly. Misconception number three. You can only get the flu once per season
1:13
Usually during a given flu season there are more than one strains of flu going around It quite possible to catch the different types of flu within that season This is why the flu shot protects against multiple strains usually the ones that are expected to be the worst offenders that year
1:26
Misconception number four, going out in cold temperatures will make you catch a cold
1:30
You've no doubt had someone in your life tell you to bundle up or risk catching a cold, and it sort of makes sense, right
1:35
People always seem to get sicker during the winter time. Still, we all know that the common cold comes from a virus, so what's the deal
1:41
In 2005, the Common Cold Center in Cardiff, UK, tested this by putting the feet of 90 students in cold water for 20 minutes
1:49
Within five days, this group had twice as many colds than the people in a control group
1:54
Lucky test subjects. But the researchers believe that it wasn't the cold water that made their subjects catch the common cold
2:00
Instead, these people probably already had the virus present in their nose, and the cold water hindered their immune system
2:06
Then the symptoms started to show. So the next time you're wanting an ice-cold foot bath, don't
2:10
Misconception number five, stomach flu equals influenza. When a person is experiencing nausea or vomiting or diarrhea
2:17
they tend to say that they have the stomach flu. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention
2:22
these can occur if you have influenza, but they're also symptoms of other viruses
2:26
Usually the flu will give more respiratory problems as opposed to stomach issues
2:30
Misconception number six if you have food poisoning the last thing you ate is to blame It might be but it also might not be Every pathogen is different so before you write that nasty Yelp review think back a little further than the past few hours
2:42
It's possible that what made you sick could have been something you ate up to three days ago. It also may not have come from food at all
2:47
You can pick up these bugs from a contaminated surface like a counter. I got food poisoning earlier this year
2:52
from a Super Bowl party, proving that I'm even terrible at watching sports. Misconception number seven
2:57
Vaccines are dangerous. Mark, do I really have to talk about this
3:01
It's kind of more of like an outlandish rumor. Okay, fine. So according to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention
3:09
the most you're probably risking when you get a vaccine is having a sore arm or a mild fever
3:14
More serious symptoms are so rare that the risk can't be accurately determined
3:18
but it's in the range of one per thousands to one per millions of doses
3:22
The same goes for risk of death. It's so hard to draw a connection between death and vaccines
3:27
but they know that the odds are very, very low. Let's compare that with the benefits of vaccination
3:32
According to the World Health Organization, immunization prevents 2-3 million deaths annually
3:36
Polio cases have decreased by over 99% since 1988, and global measles mortality has decreased 74% since 2000
3:44
Misconception number 8. The flu shot isn't worth it because it isn't that effective
3:48
I know that shots are scary but unfortunately I have to tell you that it is kind of worth it A 2013 study showed that flu vaccines led to 71 reduction in flu hospitalizations in adults The Center for Disease Control and Prevention
4:00
also announced that 90% of children who died of the flu in 2013
4:05
had not had the flu shot. It's also helpful for pregnant women. Receiving a flu shot makes it 92% more likely
4:11
for infants to avoid hospitalization for the influenza in their first six months of life
4:15
Misconception number nine, starve a fever, feed a cold. You should be eating
4:19
whether you have a fever or a cold, but it turns out you actually burn more calories
4:24
when you have a fever because your body temperature and metabolism are increased
4:28
So you should definitely be eating calories to keep up with this change in your system. Doctors do not recommend peanut butter Oreos
4:33
dipped in milk, however. I do, though. It's amazing. It's a great snack. Misconception number 10
4:38
You must have a weak immune system if you catch a cold. Actually, once you come in contact with the virus
4:42
your immune system has little to do with it. A 1992 study put the virus in subjects' noses
4:47
and found that over 90% became infected. 75% of those people went on to show symptoms of the cold
4:52
Even very healthy people can catch a cold
#education
#Other