From "Tron: Ares" to "Mickey 17", explore recent cinematic duds that were doomed from the start. We break down the factors that led to these box office disappointments.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
The Hollywood box office can be a cruel mistress, and it's certainly gotten crueler since the
0:06
pandemic heavily impacted audience attendance and habits. We've had a lot of bombs in recent years
0:13
and they happen for all kinds of different factors. Maybe the movie's concept itself is
0:18
peculiar enough to alienate the mainstream, or maybe the casting for Attache didn't inspire
0:23
much confidence at all. Whatever the reason, I'm Ewan, you're watching WhatCulture
0:28
and here are a few recent box office movie flops everyone saw coming
0:34
First up, Tron Ares. Ooh yeah, despite the passion of its fanbase, the Tron franchise has always firmly been a cult IP
0:45
with a limited, broader appeal, which in business terms seems fundamentally incompatible with a
0:51
sky-high budget. The original 1982 Tron grossed a decent $50 million against a $17 million budget
1:01
while 2010's Tron Legacy grossed a middling $409.9 million at a $170 million budget
1:10
It was easy to be pretty skeptical then about the commercial prospects of the third film
1:21
big ol' albatross around its neck that was Jared Leto's polarizing casting in the lead role
1:27
Mediocre marketing that failed to emphasize the film's must-see event appeal didn't help
1:33
nor wildly mixed reviews that ensured it failed to attract many beyond the die-hard Tron faithful
1:40
Ares ultimately fell far short of Box-Ommers predictions in its opening weekend, and after
1:45
three weekends at the time of recording is currently sitting at a brutal global total
1:50
of barely 120 million dollars, making it all of the biggest blockbuster flops in recent years
1:57
And yet, so so many people saw this one coming a mile away, and word now indicates that Disney
2:03
will be putting the big Strange Tron franchise on ice for the foreseeable future
2:09
Do you also ever find yourself locked in the existential crisis of wanting to watch the 1985
2:15
classic witness starring arison ford and kelly mcgillis but you don't know where to begin because
2:20
same me from the future you dummy if you wanted to watch the 1985 classic witness directed by peter
2:29
weir all you had to do was sign up to paramount plus using the link in the video description
2:34
this limited time offer means it's just 2.99 for two months that's five dollars off the essential
2:41
tier and $10 off Paramount Plus with Showtime which includes shows like Twin Peaks and Dexter
2:48
Original Sin. Witness and Twin Peaks? Sounds like the perfect remedy for those cold winter
2:53
nights we're having. I'm gonna go sign up right now and ignore this grave violation of the laws of
2:58
time and space. Sounds like a plan. Mickey 17 Even accepting that director Bong Joon-ho was fresh off the Oscar winning success of his global
3:09
mega hit Parasite, which grossed an astonishing $258.1 million against a mere $11.5 million budget
3:17
few were expecting his follow up Mickey 17 to repeat the same level of success
3:22
For one, it's based on a rather niche and strange sci-fi novel, which in conjunction with a $118
3:29
million budget left the break even point at almost $300 million. Sci-fi has always been a box office
3:37
wildcard considering the larger budgets they typically command, hence why the most successful
3:42
ones tend to have a broad easily understandable marketing hook, like gravity or interstellar
3:49
But Nikki 17 was more of an esoteric black comedy whose marketing didn't do a particularly stellar
3:55
job of selling its premise or tone, which coupled with good but not great reviews
4:01
caused it to settle at a hugely disappointing $133.3 million globally. In many respects, this is exactly the sort of wild swing a filmmaker gets to make after winning
4:13
Best Picture and Best Director Oscars, but it's probably fair to say that Bong won't get to play
4:18
around with this size of budget again for a good while, if ever
4:23
Next up, Elio There's no denying that the once bulletproof pigstar has struggled
4:29
massively at the Fox Office since the pandemic, when animated films were often sent direct to
4:34
streaming and families became conditioned to wait, save money and just watch them at home
4:40
Last year, Inside Out 2 did at least prove the enduring viability of Pixar's tried and true
4:46
franchises, given that it grossed an eye watering 1.699 billion worldwide, making it the highest
4:53
grossing Hollywood animation of all time, but didn't exactly suggest smooth sailing for the
4:58
studio's original IP. And so there was a lot of skepticism that their new film, Elio, could really
5:05
go the distance. With the budget estimated to be between $150 to $200 million, that left Elio
5:12
needing to gross at least $375 million to be deemed a success, but it ended up topping out
5:18
at just 154. This made it the lowest grossing non-pandemic Pixar film by a huge margin and was
5:27
basically the very predictable result of numerous adverse circumstances conspiring against it
5:33
Now for one, the marketing didn't do much to sell the uniqueness of Elio's concept or its
5:39
characters. It simply looked like a bog standard lower tier Pixar film one could easily skip and
5:45
catch on Disney Plus in a few months time. As for reviews, well they were just kind of like
5:50
nah. And additionally, attention was stolen away by the far more successful live action remakes of
5:57
Lilo and Stitch and How to Train Your Dragon. Not to mention the brilliant K-Pop Demon Hunters
6:02
which released on Netflix the very same day that Elio hit cinemas
6:06
With Elio's failure and the general struggle for original Pixar movies to hit commercially
6:12
it's little surprise that within the next few years we're gonna get Toy Story 5, Incredibles 3
6:17
and Coco 2. Next up, Mission Impossible The Final Reckoning. As ridiculous as it might seem to call any movie that grossed almost $600 million a flop
6:30
it all comes down to budgeting, and in the case of Mission Impossible The Final Reckoning
6:34
it's costs spiralled way out of control. The quote unquote final Mission Impossible movie's
6:40
price tag balloon to an estimated $400 million by the end of its production, said to be a result of
6:46
delays caused by both the pandemic and Hollywood writers strikes resulting in shooting taking more than two and a half years to actually complete Using the typical two and a half times rule for blockbusters the final reckoning therefore needed to gross in the vicinity of one billion dollars to turn a profit theatrically
7:05
which it fell far, far short of, ending its run at just under 600 million
7:10
For a more modestly priced affair of maybe, I don't know, 200 million, this would have been a fine result
7:17
And with such ludicrously high costs and following on from the commercial underperformance of the series' previous entry, Dead Reckoning Part 1, it caused the franchise to rather unceremoniously sputter out at the finish line, even if the movie itself is a pretty good time
7:32
A Big, Bold, Beautiful Journey Romance films have struggled massively since the pandemic, with a few exceptions
7:40
given the perception of many that they're not cinematic enough to warrant a trip to the movies
7:45
and why so many of them are now produced directly to streaming services
7:49
And apparently, even having the A-list likes of Colin Farrell and Marco Robby can't move the needle all that much
7:57
as evidenced by their recent romantic fantasy flop, A Big Bold Beautiful Journey
8:02
Now, to be fair, the picture's fantastical road movie premise was always going to make it a tough sell to some audiences
8:09
And the fact it was being helmed by acclaimed art house filmmaker Kogonada, whose first two
8:14
films, Columbus and After Yang, both flopped at the box office, likely didn't help much either
8:20
And you throw in reports of poor test screenings, a $45 million budget, suspiciously quiet marketing
8:27
that suggested Sony knew they had a dud on their hands, and ultimately wildly mixed reviews
8:32
that it was easy to see the films mere $20 million box office coming a mile away
8:38
It'll be interesting to see if this polarizing piece becomes something of a cult success in the years to come
8:43
but in terms of big screen business, it was finally rejected by audiences at large this year
8:49
Next up, The Accountant 2. Benaflix's 2016 thriller The Accountant was a solid box office hit
8:57
grossing an impressive $155.2 million on a $44 million budget, enough that it's genuinely surprising that it took almost an entire decade for a sequel to actually get made
9:08
However, during that time the theatrical landscape changed a lot, with mid-budget action thrillers
9:15
aimed at adult demographics struggling ever since the pandemic. And so, it probably didn't bode well
9:20
that The Accountant 2 was budgeted at almost $80 million, almost double the cost of the original
9:27
in a theatrical environment which was a little more hostile to its existence. Unsurprisingly
9:32
the sequel failed to deliver the results to pay off its larger budget, grossing $103.2 million
9:39
globally. The only saving grace here is that the film was produced and distributed by Amazon
9:44
who basically used a theatrical release to promote its subsequent streaming bow on Amazon Prime
9:50
where it drew a massive 80 million viewers within its first month on the platform
9:55
which should cushion the blow just a wee bit. On the way, Black Bag
10:00
Black Bag is sadly the sort of movie that struggles to get audiences out of their homes
10:06
A more quote unquote modest genre film without epic CGI set pieces no matter the plaudits of
10:13
its exceptional ensemble cast. Black Bag to be clear is one of my favourite movies of the year
10:18
In addition to distributor focused features barely marketing Steven Soderbergh's terrific spy thriller, it was produced for a budget of 60 million dollars, which is an undeniably high
10:28
figure for a film that largely takes place in just a few locations. Sure, accounts including
10:35
Cate Blanchett, Michael Fassbender, Naomi Harris, Reggie Jean Page and Pierce Brosnan isn't going
10:41
to come cheap, but this still seems like an inordinately high figure given the story's
10:46
confide nature and overall brevity, clocking in at just 94 minutes. Despite scoring rave reviews from many critics, Black Bag sadly topped down at just 43.4 million
10:58
globally. Though it has quite predictably performed better on streaming, helping to
11:03
mitigate some of those losses. It's certainly a shame that well crafted genre fare like this
11:08
struggles to ignite the box office nowadays, especially with so much talent behind and in
11:14
front of the camera. But the writing was probably on the wall from the very get go
11:19
Next up, the Phoenician scheme. Wes Anderson is in an immensely enviable position for any filmmaker to be in
11:27
considering that his movies are financed by Billionaire Steve Rales and his production company
11:33
Indian Paintbrush, ensuring that Anderson seemingly never has to worry about his features
11:38
underperforming commercially as they often do. But Anderson's latest film, The Phoenician Scheme
11:44
was perhaps the surest box office flop of his career, and it didn't come down to anything other
11:50
than the film's title. Even the most Wes Anderson-y Wes Anderson film prior to this had a
11:56
title that was interesting or at least amusing, but considering that a great many moviegoers have
12:02
no idea what the hell a Phoenician is and might even struggle to say it to an actual ticket teller
12:08
it put the movie on the back foot before anyone had even seen it. Then there's the sentiment
12:13
amongst some that Anderson's style is beginning to feel just a bit stale and even self-parodying
12:19
at this point in his career and so the novelty factor of this distinctive filmmaking style
12:24
isn't quite what it used to be. With that in mind, the Phoenician scheme barely cracked $40 million
12:30
on a $30 million budget, making it Anderson's lowest grossing release since 2007's The Darjeeling
12:37
Limited. All it'll take for Anderson to bounce back is a banger like the Grand Budapest Hotel
12:43
but even if that doesn't materialize, he's seemingly got a blank check to keep making
12:48
whatever the hell he wants. And honestly, good for him. Next up, Eddington
12:53
Though Ari Aster's first two films, acclaimed horror flicks, Hereditary and Midsommar, were massive successes for A24
13:02
his third feature, Bow is Afraid, which was a far more ambitious swing of a black comedy horror
13:07
was a rather predictable flop. It's mainstream alienating premise rustling up just $12.3 million
13:13
against a $50 million budget. Everything we heard pre-released about Aster's fourth film
13:21
Eddington, was that it was another not particularly commercial genre bending experiment that served
13:28
as a satire of the entire Covid era. Okay, so for one, there are many who just aren't interested
13:36
in watching a movie that revisits the most miserable period of their lives, even through
13:41
a darkly satirical lens and on top of this reviews were wildly mixed enough that even an all star cast led by Joaquin Phoenix Pedro Pascal Emma Stone and Austin Butler couldn much help it Even with a more hemmed in million budget
13:57
compared to Boaz Afraid, Eddington cracked at only $12.7 million, just a fraction more than
14:03
Astor's previous film. Yeah, it'll be interesting to see if these flops back to back impact Astor's
14:09
relationship with A24, but considering he's still one of the most singular filmmaking voices working
14:15
today, hopefully he'll keep getting to produce his visionary and not-for-everyone kind of art
14:22
Wolfman In theory, there were many, many reasons that Wolfman was set to be a solid hit at the box office
14:32
For one, it had Lee Whannell working as writer and director, who did a fantastic job reinventing
14:38
Invisible Man back in 2020 to both critical and commercial success. With the supremely talented
14:44
Christopher Abba and Julia Garner leading the small cast, and a mere $25 million budget
14:50
this seemed like an incredibly low risk, can't miss project. That was until the months leading
14:56
up to Wolfman's premiere, when there was significant backlash against the TIE Hulk
15:00
creature's apparent bleak design, prompting Whannell and company to spend much of the
15:04
marketing campaign in damage control mode. This, combined with a mid-January release
15:10
typically a dumping ground for bad horror movies, did little to help its box office tracking leading
15:16
up to its release, and Universal ultimately got desperate enough that they spoiled the Wolfman's
15:21
actual transformation in a clip released shortly before the film even came out
15:27
Wildly mixed reviews ultimately dropped just two days before its release, and basically
15:32
delivered the death knell to Wolfman's prospects, causing it to end its run at a shockingly low $35.2
15:40
million. It was a far enough result that even the film's own producer Jason Blum publicly
15:45
tweeted his disappointment about it. Which, eh, ouch. Next up, Hurry Up Tomorrow
15:52
Hurry Up Tomorrow is yet further proof that having two extremely prominent entertainers leading your
15:58
film means absolutely nothing in the modern theatrical climate, especially if the film
16:03
itself isn't that good. Even with General Tager and The Weeknd headlining this psychological
16:08
thriller from acclaimed director Trey Edward Schultz, who directed It Comes at Night and
16:13
Waves, the warnings were many and often. The Weeknd proved in HBO's controversial TV series
16:19
The Idol that his acting skills are quite limited, the intensely vague marketing failed to really
16:24
tell audiences what the hell this movie was about either, and the review embargo lifted just a day
16:30
before it hit cinemas. Unsurprisingly, the reviews were absolutely scathing, and even on a seemingly
16:37
sensible $15 million budget for a production of this size, Hurry Up Tomorrow absolutely tanked
16:43
netting just $7.8 million in cinemas. Even Ortega and The Weeknd's respective fandoms
16:50
couldn't be relied upon to make this a success. Which suffered from nuclear word of vowels after
16:55
it's opening weekend have never recovered. Enough that Hurry Up Tomorrow as a whole has largely
17:01
been forgotten already. Next up, In The Lost Worlds While George RR Martin's name might have carried some box office cache a few years ago
17:12
Game of Thrones' calamitous final season pretty much put that to bed for mainstream audiences
17:17
As such the new fantasy actioner in the Lost Lands wasn't even able to coast off the fact
17:23
that Martin wrote the story on which it is based. But there's one key factor that killed this one
17:30
dead. It's a $55 million budgeted film from Paul W.S. Anderson who hasn't enjoyed much
17:37
commercial success outside of his Mortal Kombat and Resident Evil video game adaptations
17:42
Also the trailer looked absolutely terrible. Neither Mia Jovovich nor Dave Batista are box office
17:51
drawers fitted off themselves either, and it was scarcely marketed before being quietly dropkicked
17:56
into 1370 North American cinemas earlier this year. Largely negative reviews then sealed the deal
18:04
and In The Lost Lands went on to gross a miserable 6.2 million dollars
18:10
dollars. Hoo hoo, boy that's a big ol' stinker. Needless to say, it'll be interesting to see if
18:16
Anderson can still get decently budgeted genre films made after such a catastrophic failure
18:23
Next up, The Alto Knights. It's been said time and time again that purely adult
18:29
skewing films have been struggling immensely at the box office in recent years, and The Alto Knights
18:35
provides further proof of that. Despite starring Robert De Niro in not one, but two roles
18:41
and being penned by Goodfellas writer Nicholas Pelleggi, this crime thriller was a gigantic bomb
18:48
netting just $9.6 million on a $50 million budget. This fate was painfully clear from the moment
18:55
Warner Brothers decided to call the movie The Alto Knight, a terrible title that tells Joe
19:01
public absolutely nothing about the film from a passing glance. As boring and uninspired as
19:08
generic crime thriller titles might be, they do ultimately get more eyeballs on a project
19:13
and this is definitely a case where a more approachable title would have boosted the
19:18
box office at least a little. Of course, it didn't help that even cinephiles were likely
19:23
deterred by mixed negative reviews, ensuring many likely waited to watch the Alto Knights
19:28
on streaming if they even did that at all. Next up, The Life of Chuck
19:35
In another timeline where Neon released The Life of Chuck in 2024 and not 2025
19:41
it's easy to see it being way more successful, even if it wasn't an outright hit. After all
19:48
Mike Flanagan's acclaimed adaptation of Stephen King's fantasy story won the Audience Award at
19:53
last year's Toronto International Film Festival, which is usually a reliable indicator that a
19:58
film will be nominated for the Best Picture Oscar nomination in the coming years. But rather than
20:03
capitalize on all this buzz, Neil left the life of Chuck on the shelf for 9 whole months. Only
20:10
releasing it this past June when all that free release buzz had just basically gone BOOM
20:16
There were certainly other factors to consider as well though. The title tells you almost nothing
20:21
about the movie and the marketing seemed almost afraid of fully detailing its tricky premise
20:27
painting it instead as a more straightforward, mawkish melodrama. And finally even those who
20:32
wanted to see it couldn't necessarily do so easily, as Nealon barely released it into a thousand
20:38
cinemas domestically Though we still don know the movie full budget there absolutely no way it turned a profit with a box office haul of just million If Neon had struck while the iron was hot last year it surely would have performed
20:53
way better. Instead, Flammagin's film was a resolute flop and has little to no chance of scoring
20:58
any Oscar recognition early next year. Next up, Honey Doped. In 2025, there was always going to be a limited big screen appeal for a neo-noir
21:10
no matter who's starring or making it, because it's a genre many are quite content to catch on
21:15
streaming a few weeks later instead. While one might assume that having one of the Coen brothers
21:21
that would be Ethan Coen in the director's chair, might carry some commercial sway
21:26
his previous solo venture last year's Drive Away Dolls categorically proved that not to be the
21:32
case. That film, which also starred Marvick Qualley in a different role, grossed just $7.9
21:38
million globally, and even with Honey Don't additionally counting Aubrey Plaza, Chris
21:44
Evans and Charlie Day among its ensemble, there wasn't that much hope for it. It probably didn't
21:49
help either that the film misguidedly premiered at Cannes back in May, allowing mixed to negative
21:55
reviews to linger around for three full months before its full premiere. Between this and
22:00
terrible audience scores, it wasn't in any way shocking that the picture made just 6.7 million
22:06
theatrically, which was even less than drive away dolls. With a third entry into this thematic B
22:12
movie trilogy, Go Beavers already in the works, it probably wouldn't be a surprise if that one
22:18
ends up skewing even lower on the box office register. Next up, The Ritual
22:24
Horror is one of the most reliable of all genres where box office is concerned. It's pretty much
22:30
critic proof, and that's especially true when we're talking about exorcism films
22:35
So on paper The Ritual should have had something going for it, especially as it stars Al Pacino
22:42
and Dan Stevens as priests who reluctantly team up to save an allegedly possessed woman
22:47
But distributor XYZ Films absolutely buried this one, barely marketing it at all before
22:54
quietly releasing it this past summer without screening it for most critics, which means the
22:59
writing was firmly on the wall. Unsurprisingly it was near universally panned by the press and
23:05
even undemanding audiences craving some basic possession thrills didn't rate it much either
23:11
As such it was easy to predict its $5.7 million final haul which oh my god is pretty bad. While
23:18
the ritual's full budget hasn't been publicly disclosed, it clearly wasn't made for a pittance
23:24
so there's no chance it turned a profit theatrically. On the way, Love Hurts. Love Hurts is a film that a lot of people were rooting for. A romantic
23:35
action comedy vehicle for the great Ki-Huai Kwan who seemed to finally be getting juicy roles
23:41
following his 2023 Best Supporting Actor Oscar win for Everything Everywhere All At Once
23:47
With its appealing lead actor and a release just before Valentine's Day there was potential that
23:53
strong reviews could push the $18 million film to solid-ish success, but as Love Hurts' release
24:00
neared, it became clear that Universal had no confidence in it. For one, they barely marketed
24:06
it at all, and then the review embargo lifted just a day before release, and said reviews were also
24:12
largely negative. Then there's the 83 minute long runtime, which left many assuming that it had been
24:18
hacked to pieces in post production, and the fact that many simply found the advertised romance
24:24
between Quan and the 20 years younger Ariana DeBose totally unappealing. And so Love Hurts
24:30
couldn't even recoup it's base budget, grossing $17.6 million and basically vanishing off the
24:37
face of the earth within two weekends. A frustrating outcome as Quan clearly deserves so much better
24:44
than this. Next up, Ballerina. While you can't really blame Lionsgate for wanting to expand the
24:51
John Wick series with spinoffs aplenty, there is a fundamental inescapable fact that Keanu Reeves
24:58
is John Wick, both as a character and a franchise. Although I'm hoping that theory isn't true because
25:04
the spinoff involving Donnie L and Rina Sawayama, I'm really rooting for that one. But yes, anyway
25:09
Even though Reeves was heavily marketed as making a supporting appearance in Ballerina
25:15
it simply wasn't enough to lure most fans of the series out of the house
25:20
As kickass and skilled an actress as Ana de Amas is, Ballerina's marketing largely made it look like a
25:25
paint the numbers action thriller with action sequences a fair few runs to lower the main
25:31
John Wick franchise. All that pre-release hubbub about extensive reshoots probably didn't help
25:37
shift that perception either. It was perfect, wait for streaming fodder, which is hardly what any
25:43
studio bankrolling a film to the tune of 90 million dollars wants to hear, which is just 10 million
25:48
less than the cost of John Wick Chapter 4 despite Reeves appearing for just a few brief scenes
25:54
Ballerina ended up grossing just 137.2 million, leaving it miles away from profitability and
26:00
grossing less than every single mainline Wick movie except the first which was produced for
26:05
just 30 million back in 2014. As such, well it's little surprise that Lionsgate is now pushing
26:11
extra hard for John Wick Chapter 5 to go into production. Whatever that might look like isn't
26:16
during the ending of Chapter 4 and also the state of Keanu Reeves' needs
26:21
And lastly we have The Unbreakable Boy. It's never ever a good time when a film sits on the
26:28
studio shelf for years, and so it was a given that biographical drama The Unbreakable Boy
26:35
was destined to flop. Even though faith based films tend to perform well at the box office of
26:41
the demographic who will reliably turn up to support them, Lionsgate didn't make much effort
26:47
at all with this particular one. The movie was shot in late 2020 and didn't release until February
26:53
this year. Apparently a result of the political climate in the US and the one to release the
26:59
unbreakable boy at the quote unquote right time. Which is very suspicious and weird
27:06
But I digress. Despite landing an A cinema score and a stonking 97
27:12
audience approval rating on the tomatometer, it seems that awareness wasn't there for it
27:18
Perhaps in part because Lionsgate released it in under 2000 theatres domestically. Given the
27:24
wildly hit and miss track record of production company Kingdom Story Company, it was easy to
27:30
doubt the prospects of this particular film, especially with such an egregious and weird release delay


