0:00
my name is Dr john Watson and what I'm
0:02
about to tell you will destroy
0:03
everything you think you know what if
0:06
everything we knew about Sherlock Holmes
0:08
was a lie What if the man I trusted with
0:11
my life the man the world praised as the
0:13
genius of Baker Street was something
0:15
else entirely Not a detective not a
0:18
savior but the architect of every crime
0:20
we thought he solved this is my
0:23
confession this is the case I never
0:26
dared publish until now
0:29
you believe you know Sherlock Holmes but
0:32
you only know the story he allowed you
0:33
to hear he was a man of logic of method
0:37
of mystery but beneath the brilliance
0:40
lived something cold calculating and
0:43
inhuman he didn't fight chaos he used it
0:48
he didn't solve crimes he managed them
0:51
and I Watson his most trusted companion
0:54
may have been his longest experiment
0:57
before Holmes stepped foot in Baker
0:58
Street he wasn't interested in justice
1:01
he was interested in behavior in
1:03
patterns and how people broke as a young
1:06
student Holmes spent less time with
1:08
classmates more time in the morg or in
1:10
libraries scribbling questions like
1:12
"What compels a man to kill when no one
1:14
is watching?" Professors praised his
1:17
intellect but worried about his
1:18
obsession he wrote essays not on law but
1:22
on the perfection of the undetectable
1:24
crime to him crime was not evil it was
1:28
elegant he once told me "The perfect
1:32
crime is not the one that goes unsolved
1:35
it's the one that is solved but blames
1:37
the wrong man." I thought he was being
1:40
clever now I know he meant it in the
1:43
year 1888 London bled fear the Ripper
1:46
killing shocked the world holmes never
1:49
officially joined the case he said he
1:51
found it vulgar but late at night he
1:54
would study the details sketch the
1:56
wounds pace endlessly muttering things
1:59
only the killer should know he received
2:01
a letter once an anonymous taunt written
2:04
in ink smeared by blood it matched the
2:07
style of the Ripper letters sent to the
2:09
police when I asked him about it he
2:11
simply said "That man knows
2:15
The murder stopped without warning no
2:17
killer was found but Holmes became more
2:20
famous than ever he used those murders
2:22
to step into the public eye was he
2:25
chasing the Ripper or wearing the mask
2:27
It took me years to notice but every
2:30
case we solved every criminal caught
2:33
felt too clean too dramatic the clues
2:36
too perfect the motives too symbolic he
2:39
always arrived just before the crime
2:41
scene was disturbed always knew the
2:43
layout the relationships the weaknesses
2:46
of the suspect once I confronted him you
2:49
always arrived too quickly Holmes how He
2:53
smiled because I know where the crime
2:56
begins Watson at the time I thought it
2:59
meant he was brilliant now I know it
3:02
meant he was involved
3:04
morardi the name that haunts the legend
3:07
the so-called Napoleon of Crime Holmes's
3:10
greatest enemy but I never met him no
3:14
one did there were no portraits no
3:16
records no witnesses just Holmes's word
3:19
i began to wonder if Morardi was real or
3:22
if Holmes created him to be the villain
3:24
he needed you see if Holmes was ever
3:26
suspected of orchestrating crimes having
3:29
a shadowy criminal mastermind to blame
3:31
would protect him every wild case every
3:34
threat of evil in London was pinned to
3:36
Morardi but who placed the pin Holmes
3:40
the Reichenbach falls holmes's final
3:43
confrontation with Morardi or so I
3:46
believed they struggled and fell or so
3:49
the letter said there was no body no
3:52
blood only Holmes's handwriting on damp
3:55
parchment i mourned i moved on but years
3:59
later he returned he told me he had
4:01
faked his death to dismantle Morardi's
4:04
empire but what empire No syndicate rose
4:09
what if Holmes didn't escape a villain
4:11
What if he buried a story What if there
4:14
was never a Morardi to begin with I
4:16
trusted Holmes more than anyone but
4:19
trust is not the same as truth
4:22
over time I began to keep my own notes
4:25
private ones details he overlooked or
4:27
rather details he was too prepared for
4:30
why did he know what no one else did Why
4:32
did every crime seem to benefit his
4:34
reputation One night I confronted him
4:38
tell me Holmes how do you know what the
4:40
killer knew He stared then he smiled
4:44
because I see what they see Watson and
4:46
that was when I stopped asking questions
4:49
and started writing them down years
4:51
after Holmes retired I found an old
4:53
chest in my attic in it were my true
4:56
journals the ones I never shared and
4:59
with them a memory I had long buried the
5:02
look in Holmes's eyes during a murder
5:04
trial he testified in he smiled not at
5:07
justice being done but at the beauty of
5:12
he didn't just enjoy solving the crime
5:13
he enjoyed creating it some killers seek
5:16
blood others seek recognition holmes
5:19
sought control and we gave it to him
5:22
irene Adler the woman who outwitted him
5:25
or did she Holmes allowed her to go free
5:28
perhaps to preserve the illusion of
5:32
microoft his older brother they met
5:35
often yet rarely disagreed was Microoft
5:38
a check on Sherlock or his enabler The
5:41
deeper I searched the less I believed
5:44
was Sherlock even his real name He once
5:47
said to me Watson a name is only a
5:50
costume what was the man I followed all
5:52
those years Detective hero monster
5:56
perhaps all today Sherlock Holmes is
5:59
fiction's greatest detective
6:01
immortalized in ink and screen but the
6:04
real Holmes the man behind the myth left
6:07
a trail not of clues but of consequences
6:11
he turned crime into theater and the
6:14
world into his stage we wanted to
6:16
believe in genius so we ignored the cost
6:20
the real mystery was never the crime it
6:22
was the man solving it so what if
6:25
Sherlock Holmes was the villain all
6:27
along What if I Watson was never the
6:30
biographer of a hero but the chronicler
6:33
of a master manipulator What if this
6:36
story wasn't about justice but about how
6:38
far genius will go to remain adored He
6:42
didn't solve crimes he curated them he
6:45
didn't catch killers he made them this
6:48
is the final case the one the world
6:50
refused to see the case of Sherlock
