Up next in 10
The doctor answers a question about a patient who suffered a fifth metatarsal fracture and got poor advice from her doctor. The doctor offers suggestions as to what can be done about the problem.
Learn more at https://www.foot-pain-explained.com
@marcbarry1000
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
here's a question from Sally in Los
0:02
Angeles she's asking about a displaced
0:05
fifth metatarsal
0:07
fracture she states I fell down the
0:09
stairs landing on my right foot Twisted
0:12
it and was diagnosed with a displaced
0:14
commuted fifth metatarsal fracture I was
0:17
put in a non-weightbearing cast for one
0:19
week and then an aircast boot the doctor
0:23
said I could start to walk with the boot
0:24
as much as pain could be
0:26
tolerated after 1 month I went back for
0:29
another xray but it looked exactly the
0:31
same as before the doctor had previously
0:34
told me that my bone would be able to
0:36
heal in proper alignment but obviously
0:39
it wasn't going to happen without any
0:40
external
0:42
reinforcement so I asked him what
0:44
options I had to realign the bone he
0:47
said it was only possible with
0:49
surgery however he didn't seem to
0:51
recommend the surgery citing the
0:53
possible complications and a need to
0:56
remove whatever bone callous that had
0:58
formed so he just told me to continue
1:00
wearing the aircast boot and let the
1:02
bone heal in its misaligned position I
1:06
was concerned about the long-term
1:07
problems of leaving the foot like that
1:09
so I went to seek a second
1:11
opinion this time the doctor recommended
1:14
surgery to put in bone grafts to allow
1:16
the bone to heal in proper
1:18
alignment however due to various reasons
1:21
I was not able to do the surgery
1:25
immediately and now my x-ray shows a
1:27
malunion otherwise known as a non Union
1:31
this is about 4 months after my injury
1:33
occurred I am off the aircast boot now
1:36
and I'm walking with normal shoes the
1:39
doctor says to put off the surgery and
1:41
continue walking and let the bone
1:43
rebuild there are occasional aches at
1:46
the side of my foot where the bone is
1:48
injured and there was once a sharp pain
1:50
that occurred followed by one week of
1:52
recurrent tingling pain at the side of
1:54
my foot since then I didn't dare to flex
1:58
my foot too much as I was afraid the
1:59
sharp pain was due to nerve injury or
2:01
something like that I am not sure if
2:04
this is the right direction to go to
2:06
continue walking and hoping that there
2:08
won't be any problems down the road and
2:11
whether the bone will be able to regain
2:13
enough strength for me to return to
2:15
normal sports activities like running I
2:18
am female 28 years old don't smoke and
2:21
drink and have lost some weight since my
2:24
injury it seems I'm losing bone density
2:27
in the area and the doctor said I can
2:29
sleep slowly recover it by putting
2:31
weight on my foot thank you for any help
2:35
my response hi Sally I do not want to
2:38
sound like a Monday Morning
2:40
Quarterback but had you walked into my
2:42
office with the first x-ray I would have
2:44
explained to you that you had a very
2:46
slim chance of that fracture healing
2:48
properly you have less than 50% bone to-
2:51
bone
2:52
approximation and the distal end of the
2:54
bone which is the front end of the bone
2:57
has displaced down onto the proximal
2:59
back portion of the bone this means that
3:02
if by some miracle the bone had actually
3:04
healed your fifth metatarsal bone would
3:06
have ended up being excessively short
3:09
which down the road you would have had
3:10
additional foot problems simply because
3:12
the architecture of the metatarsal bones
3:14
would now be
3:16
misaligned at 28 years of age and good
3:19
health you are a perfect candidate for
3:21
surgery the potential for success far
3:24
outweighs any potential
3:26
complications the main complication of
3:29
this type of repair is a non-union and
3:31
you have that anyway if for whatever
3:34
reason you decided not to have surgery
3:36
at the very least you should have been
3:38
totally non-weightbearing on
3:40
crutches and should have been given a
3:42
bone
3:43
stimulator this combination should have
3:45
been instituted for a minimum of 6 weeks
3:48
with the possibility of a longer period
3:50
of time depending on your
3:52
progress having said all that broken
3:55
bones can heal in an abnormal position
3:57
and people can function it all depends
4:00
on what your definition of function is
4:03
if you never fall again or even trip or
4:05
stub your foot the bone might not
4:08
refracture if you never participate in
4:10
any sport or workout again the bone
4:13
might not
4:14
refracture in other words if you change
4:17
your lifestyle and accommodate this
4:18
problem you might get by for the next 60
4:21
years or so but truthfully I doubt it
4:25
this does not take into account the
4:27
potential problems that can occur from
4:29
the new position I of your fifth toe and
4:31
the resulting fifth metatarsal bone
4:33
which is now
4:34
shorter my opinion is that you should
4:36
consider having
4:38
surgery it will probably require a bone
4:40
graft and a fair amount of Hardware to
4:42
keep the bone in alignment you will need
4:45
to be off the foot for a period of time
4:47
but once you have made the commitment to
4:49
fix this problem and put in the time
4:51
involved you should be able to resume
4:53
your life good luck with your decision
#Injury