0:00
It's not every day that we say goodbye
0:01
to someone and expect to never see them
0:03
again. However, that was the case for
0:05
one husband when he dropped his wife at
0:07
the hospital. What was meant to be a
0:09
routine appointment quickly turned into
0:11
a decades long mystery. In the end,
0:14
Flora Stevens was found in the most
0:15
unexpected place after she was missing
0:17
for 42 years. But that wasn't the end of
0:20
the mystery. In fact, for officers
0:22
working the case, it was just the start
0:24
of many more questions to come. But
0:26
before we start, smash the like button
0:28
and make sure to subscribe if you
0:29
haven't and hit that notification bell
0:31
so that you won't miss any new stories.
0:33
Like many others, it seemed Flora
0:35
Stevens was living a normal life. She
0:38
was 36 years old and living in
0:39
Montichello, New York back in 1,975.
0:44
But everything changed one fateful
0:46
night. Florence, called Flora by her
0:48
friends and family, was married to
0:50
Robert Stevens, but had been feeling
0:52
under the weather and needed to see a
0:53
doctor. Robert drove his wife to the
0:55
hospital on the night of August 3,
1:00
and assumed he would be picking her up a
1:03
couple of hours later. However, the area
1:05
was a busy tourist spot, meaning it was
1:07
easy to lose people in the crowd. That
1:09
was something Robert was about to learn
1:11
the hard way. At the time, many thought
1:13
that Flora and Robert Stevens had
1:15
everything they could need. After all,
1:17
Flora had a great job at the Concord, a
1:19
hotel that was a booming part of the
1:21
Catskills, a mountain range in New York,
1:24
and welcomed thousands of visitors a
1:26
year. The summer of 1,975
1:29
had been no exception. At the time, the
1:32
Concord had around 1,200 rooms, with
1:35
Flora seemingly making a lot of income
1:38
through tips she received from work. The
1:40
area was a huge hit with visitors to the
1:42
area, and the hotel had no plans of
1:44
shutting down anytime soon. Just because
1:46
things seemed stable in Flora's life
1:49
didn't mean that was true. Robert
1:51
Stevens dropped his wife at the
1:53
hospital, left, and returned 2 hours
1:55
later. However, it wasn't until he went
1:57
looking for Flora Stevens that he
1:59
realized she was nowhere to be seen. He
2:01
looked everywhere, but it was as though
2:03
Flora had disappeared into thin air.
2:05
Robert immediately called the police,
2:07
but things weren't looking good. The
2:09
officers started to dig around into
2:11
Flora's past to see if there were any
2:13
clues about where she could have gone or
2:15
someone who might be out to hurt her.
2:16
They learned she was once a student at
2:18
Lincoln High School in New York and
2:20
about Flora's marriage to Robert. But
2:22
that's where the trail started to go
2:24
cold. From the moment Flora Stevens
2:26
disappeared. Officers did everything
2:28
they could to see if they could learn
2:30
about where she could have gone.
2:31
However, Flora didn't seem to have any
2:33
family in the area, and none of her
2:35
friends or co-workers had been given
2:37
clues about someone who might want to
2:39
see her disappear for good. No one could
2:41
figure out what happened after Robert
2:43
Stevens dropped his wife at the
2:44
hospital. Although many people from the
2:46
neighborhood joined in the search for
2:47
the missing woman, nothing ever came to
2:50
light. The case was growing colder by
2:52
the day, and with no new clues, the
2:54
investigators were running out of
2:55
options. Try as they might, the
2:57
investigators working on Flora Stevens
2:59
case couldn't make evidence appear out
3:01
of nowhere. Plus, they had fewer
3:03
techniques at their disposal, meaning
3:05
they were largely working with the
3:06
things people saw or any evidence left
3:09
around the area. CCTV wasn't largely
3:11
used in the US until the 1,990s,
3:15
despite being invented in the 20s. To
3:18
make matters worse, DNA testing didn't
3:20
become a part of US police cases until
3:25
Meaning that even if clues had been left
3:27
at the scene where Flora disappeared,
3:30
the police had no way to test anything.
3:32
There was no cell phone to track, no
3:34
internet to ask for help, and Flora's
3:36
husband was as clueless as everyone
3:38
else. Although they were doing
3:39
everything they could, it wasn't long
3:41
before the investigators working on
3:43
Flora Stevens case had to admit they had
3:45
run out of leads. Robert Stevens was
3:47
also doing everything he could to track
3:49
down his missing wife. But with nowhere
3:52
to turn, the days turned into weeks, and
3:54
the weeks turned into months. It became
3:57
clear to everyone involved that they
3:59
weren't getting anywhere, and they had
4:00
no choice but to mark Flora's case as
4:03
unsolved and file it away. While new
4:05
clues would have helped, they had to
4:07
continue solving other crimes. Still,
4:10
Robert was desperate for closure and
4:12
knew he would struggle to move on with
4:14
his life without answers. Statistics
4:16
show thousands of women and girls go
4:18
missing every year in the US, making it
4:20
difficult to link evidence to a specific
4:22
case. Modern technologies like DNA
4:25
testing and cell phone tracking weren't
4:27
available when Flora disappeared,
4:29
further complicating the investigation.
4:31
Despite promising leads, Solomon had to
4:33
sift through countless cases of missing
4:35
women. It became clear this was no
4:37
one-man job. He needed a team. Together,
4:41
they began the massive task of sorting
4:43
through cold cases, hoping to identify
4:45
the remains and perhaps close Flora's
4:47
file once and for all. Solomon, like
4:50
many skilled detectives, trusted his
4:52
instincts. To gain better insight, he
4:55
returned to the area where Flora was
4:57
last seen. Although the landscape had
5:02
he hoped for something thing that could
5:04
move the case forward. A new clue soon
5:07
emerged. Items found with the remains
5:09
tied the woman to Sullivan County where
5:11
Flora once lived. This narrowed the
5:14
field to just a handful of unresolved
5:16
cases. One file remained a potential
5:18
match. But the situation was still
5:20
unclear. Eliminating all other
5:22
possibilities was the only way to be
5:24
sure. With Laura's name now on
5:26
everyone's radar, Solomon needed solid
5:29
proof. That meant matching DNA from the
5:32
remains to a living relative.
5:34
Unfortunately, the team discovered there
5:35
were no known surviving family members
5:37
to provide a comparison. The case once
5:40
again stalled. One of the main
5:43
challenges in solving Flora's
5:44
disappearance was the passage of time.
5:46
She had gone missing in 1,975
5:50
and with each passing year, the evidence
5:52
had grown colder. The lack of
5:54
technological tools at the time meant
5:56
much of what could have been collected
5:58
back then was never documented.
5:59
Compounding the problem, most of the
6:01
original investigators were now gone,
6:04
taking their knowledge with them. The
6:05
break the team finally needed came when
6:07
they learned more about the
6:08
identification initially found with the
6:10
remains. At last, they had a name to
6:13
match the body. But things weren't as
6:15
they seemed. Shockingly, the remains
6:17
didn't belong to Flora Stevens after
6:19
all, despite the overwhelming
6:21
similarities. The woman had also worked
6:23
in the Catkills and was reported missing
6:25
around the same time as Flora. The
6:27
coincidences were eerie, but it only
6:29
meant one thing. Detectives now had two
6:32
unsolved cases on their hands, and still
6:34
no closer path to finding Flora. Much of
6:37
the modern investigative tools like the
6:40
Neoo's database weren't available when
6:42
Flora vanished in 1,975.
6:46
Names, which helps cross reference
6:48
missing persons with unidentified
6:50
remains, wasn't launched until 2007.
6:54
With such a large backlog, Flora's case
6:56
was never entered. This lack of access
6:58
had placed her case at a technological
7:00
disadvantage for decades. Still, the
7:03
similarities between the two
7:04
disappearances made investigators wonder
7:06
if something more sinister had happened.
7:08
Two women missing from the same region
7:10
at the same time with similar prolesent
7:13
was a pattern too suspicious to ignore.
7:15
Was this the work of a serial offender?
7:17
Could Flora be another victim in a
7:19
broader scheme that had gone undetected
7:21
for over 40 years? The mystery had
7:23
haunted Robert Stevens, Flora's husband,
7:26
for decades. He was one of the last to
7:28
see her, making him a suspect at one
7:30
point, though he was later cleared.
7:32
Determined to find answers, Robert never
7:35
gave up. He spent years searching,
7:37
replaying the past, hoping each
7:39
anniversary would bring closure, but it
7:41
never did. Tragically, Robert passed
7:43
away 10 years after Flora vanished,
7:46
never learning what had happened to his
7:47
wife. His death left another gap in the
7:50
investigation. No one remained to answer
7:52
questions about Flora's final days. Any
7:55
small details that might have mattered
7:57
had vanished with him, making the case
7:59
even harder to crack. Detective Rich
8:01
Morgan now had to rely solely on the
8:03
case files and any modern tools he could
8:05
access. When it seemed all leads had
8:07
dried up, he decided to try something
8:09
unconventional searching, the national
8:11
social security databases. It was a long
8:14
shot, but worth a try. To Morgan's
8:16
astonishment, Flora's social security
8:18
number was still active. Someone had
8:21
been using it. While identity theft was
8:23
a possibility, the use of Flora's number
8:25
was still the most promising lead in
8:27
years. The trail led Morgan to Lel,
8:30
Massachusetts to 150 mi from where Flora
8:33
had gone missing and to a woman in an
8:35
assisted living facility. Morgan called
8:37
the facility and explained the case. The
8:39
response was unexpected. Someone named
8:42
Flora was indeed a resident. She went by
8:44
the name Flora Harris, not Stevens, but
8:47
the pieces began to align. The woman had
8:50
been living there since 2001.
8:52
This left detectives with two theories.
8:55
Either Flora had been living under a new
8:57
identity all this time, or someone had
8:59
stolen her information and possibly
9:01
played a role in her disappearance. The
9:03
implications were massive. Was Flora
9:06
alive and safe, or was this an impostor?
9:09
There was only one way to find out.
9:11
Detective Rich Morgan made the drive to
9:13
Massachusetts, carrying with him years
9:15
of unanswered questions and the hope
9:17
that he was about to bring closure to
9:19
one of the most mysterious
9:20
disappearances in recent history. Within
9:22
a few hours, the truth would finally be
9:25
revealed. The idea of stealing someone's
9:27
identity isn't new. Some do it to escape
9:30
legal trouble, others for darker
9:32
motives. Detectives could only uncover
9:35
the truth once they reach the assisted
9:37
living facility. If someone had truly
9:39
been living as Flora Steven, known as
9:41
Flora Harris, might have gotten away
9:43
with it for decades. Knowing the woman
9:45
at the care home suffered from dementia,
9:47
the team brought photos to help jog her
9:49
memory. One was of Flora herself. Upon
9:52
seeing it, the woman whispered, "Me."
9:55
When shown a photo of Robert, she
9:57
recognized him. She also clung to a
9:59
picture of the Concord, the hotel where
10:01
she once worked. Detective Rich Morgan
10:03
later recalled, "She wouldn't let that
10:06
photo go." After 42 years, the mystery
10:09
of Flora Stevens disappearance in August
10:14
had at least one answer. She had been
10:16
found. Yet many questions remained.
10:19
Where had she been all those years? Why
10:21
had she vanished? Unfortunately, Flora's
10:24
dementia had taken its toll. She
10:26
remembered little of her past and had
10:28
spent the last 16 years in the care
10:30
home. Authorities have remained quiet
10:32
about certain details. Due to privacy
10:34
laws, they couldn't reveal why Flora
10:36
initially appeared at the hospital in
10:41
However, they did note a nearby bus
10:43
station and suggested Flora may have
10:45
chosen to leave on her own. The mystery
10:47
of how Flora ended up in the assisted
10:49
living facility was also eventually
10:51
solved. A court-appointed guardian from
10:53
New York had been paying her bills for
10:55
years. Mabuva, meanwhile, tried piecing
10:58
together bits of her life. Flora hinted
11:00
at an abusive marriage, claiming Robert
11:03
mistreated her. She also shared memories
11:05
of attending Woodstock in 1,969
11:09
and working as a hair stylist. Some
11:11
believe Flora still remembers more than
11:13
she lets on, but that's speculation.
11:16
What we do know is only the first 36
11:19
years of her life. Since at least 2001,
11:22
she had lived under the name Flora
11:24
Harris, and the case was one of the rare
11:26
ones that investigators managed to
11:28
resolve after more than four decades.
11:31
When Flora Stevens was found, she was 78
11:34
years old. Had the detectives not
11:36
brought those old photos, they might
11:38
have missed her completely. Further
11:39
investigation revealed she had lived in
11:41
care homes across New York City and New
11:43
Hampshire before settling in Lel, where
11:45
her memory began to deteriorate. While
11:47
the full story of Flora's disappearance
11:49
may never be known, one thing is
11:51
certain. She vanished on her own terms
11:53
and managed to stay hidden for over 40
11:56
years. In the end, her disappearance
11:58
wasn't just a mystery solved, but a life