He needs to be removed.
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Carol, we've also learned through an FEC filing report that Judge Juan Merchan, who presided
0:05
over Trump's New York arraignment, made a campaign donation to President Biden's 2020
0:11
presidential campaign. It was for $15. Are the optics problematic here? I think the optics are a bit problematic
0:20
To be clear, the donations were made in 2020 before Judge Merchan had either the Trump
0:26
Organization case assigned to him or obviously this case. But it is troubling optics, I think, for any judge to have made a political contribution
0:36
and then to have a party who is either the beneficiary or not the beneficiary of that
0:42
political contribution before that judge in court. Now, it was a trivial amount of money, and this is a trial-level judge
0:51
The judge in this case is not the ultimate trier of fact. The jury is, but the judge does call some balls and some strikes during the course of
0:58
the trial. And if there's a conviction, the judge is responsible for sentencing
1:02
That is all subject to review on appeal. However, it is probably not the best course of action for a judge to have made political
1:11
contributions while a sitting judge with the possibility that such cases can arise before him
1:18
Carol, earlier this week, The New York Times' Maggie Hamerman, who's done extensive reporting
1:21
on Trump, reported that he is worried about the probes currently underway with the Georgia
1:26
2020 election interference case bothering him personally. His aides are privately worried about the Mar-a-Lago doctrine
1:33
Hey everyone, Carmine Sabia here for Explain America. That is indeed troubling news
1:39
How are you supposed to get a fair trial if you're former President Donald Trump, when
1:43
you have a judge who literally donated to the campaign of Joe Biden
1:48
I mean, he donated against you. It could have been for a dollar
1:52
He donated for somebody to beat you. And now he's presiding over your case
1:58
His daughter worked on the campaign of the person you face in the election
2:04
And that's not to say that Judge Marchand cannot be impartial and fair
2:09
You can't say that. His job as a judge is separate from his political beliefs, but the optics of this are brutal
2:18
In fact, they're so brutal that even if Bragg got a conviction, which Alan Dershowitz has
2:24
said is likely, this alone could be grounds for appeal. The judge has literally donated to Joe Biden
2:33
Think about this. This is like having a baseball umpire in a Yankees and Red Sox game who has a house full
2:42
of Red Sox memorabilia, has bought Red Sox season tickets. Can't be fair and impartial
2:49
And now that the people know that this judge has done, it's going to be hard enough to
2:54
get a fair and impartial trial in New York City to begin with. You know, when you have a jury made up of people who, I mean, the city voted overwhelmingly
3:04
against Trump. So it's going to be very hard to get conservatives on that jury, Trump supporters on that jury
3:10
And even if you do, those people have to go home and live their lives if Trump, you know
3:14
doesn't get convicted. And people are going to be furious at them
3:18
And now you've got a judge who donated to the guy whose Justice Department is, is, you
3:25
know, investigating you right now. And the guy who you're taking on again in 2024, should you win the Republican nomination
3:32
Conflict of interest doesn't even begin to describe the severity of this situation
3:37
This judge needs to recuse himself and quickly or, and, and, or it could be either one
3:45
They need to change a venue. If you ask me, I think both things need to happen, which is why I said and, or both of
3:51
those things need to happen. You need to get a new judge and you need to change a venue someplace like Staten Island
3:56
You're keeping it in the state of New York, but it's more diverse in terms of the way it votes
4:00
There's Democrats, there's Republicans. But to put Trump on trial with a judge who supported Joe Biden in his city that overwhelmingly
4:08
voted against him, this is, you know, a kangaroo court, just like, just like Trump said, it's
4:13
totally unfair and it should not be happening in America. This reeks of political persecution, even if that's not what it is
4:22
The optics are just abhorrent. Folks, thank you for joining us here at Explain America
4:27
Again, I'm Carmine Sabia. Please remember to like, comment, share, and subscribe
4:31
It really helps us out. We love you guys. God bless you. Take care, everybody
Politics
Campaigns & Elections


