Massive Supreme Court Ruling - Good News For Trump

Hey ladies and gentlemen this is Carmine Sabia for Explain America and the Supreme Court has just

issued a decision that could be massive for former President Donald Trump. Before we get started

please make sure you like, comment, share and subscribe and you know guys with this election

coming up we're going to be bringing you and our members some exclusive news that is members only

so if you're supporting Trump in this election smash that join button become a member of this

channel. The Supreme Court today issued a ruling that said basically the government of the United

States is allowed to go to social media companies and try to get posts removed that they consider

disinformation. Now the problem with this is they're not just asking like you or I would ask

they're asking with the pressure of the United States government and that's a whole different

thing. Now justices Thomas and Alito and Gorsuch they disagreed on this decision and they dissent

it however conservative justices Roberts, Barrett and Kavanaugh they sided with the liberals on this

That being said this is to me a bad decision for the first amendment. It's a bad decision for free

speech. It's a bad decision for conservatives but there is a silver lining to this cloud

in that it could be a good decision for Donald Trump because if you look at what the court is

saying they're giving broad powers to the government here. Well Trump in his immunity case

is arguing broad government powers, broad executive powers. If they follow that line of thinking

well then they have to extend that to the former president of the United States

and the executive power he had at the time he did what he did during the election

So if you follow by that logic while we are smarting at this decision today which I think was

tremendously incorrect but I will say was decided basically on standing and not on the merits

even still not a great decision but but the silver lining is it could be fantastic for Donald Trump

when it comes to immunity. I want you to watch this clip on the ruling and the details and then

leave me your comments let me know what you think. Evidence before they vote in November. Yeah Ellie

I want to get your take on that too but we should note to our viewers we did get one a decision from

the Supreme Court very important one and Ellie you can comment on that one as well. The Supreme Court

said the White House and federal agencies such as the FBI may continue to urge social media platforms

to take down content the government use as misinformation. This is viewed as a victory for

the Biden administration technical if not an important one. Yeah so what do you think. Let me

talk about this case that just came down the first one today. So you may remember about a year or so

ago a group of Republican state attorneys general and a group of internet users social media users

sued the Biden administration. They said you are violating the first amendment when you were during

COVID primarily during COVID but other issues too when you were reaching out to social media companies

saying you need to take this post down you need to moderate this post and the question was does that

violate the first amendment. The Supreme Court has now found by a six to three ruling not your usual

concern it's actually a cross ideological majority that the people who sued do not have standing

meaning state AGs and people who may use Twitter or Facebook you don't have enough of an injury from

this to even bring the lawsuit. So they didn't even reach the first amendment question the first

amendment merits the Supreme Court just said six to three you're out of luck this lawsuit's no good

go back to the drawing board. Is that kind of taking a pass on deciding some of the more key

constitutional issues? It's a procedural off-ramp but it matters I mean standing matters in our

court you can't just bring a lawsuit because something bothers you or offends you you have to be able to show some tangible injury and just to remind our viewers we saw the Mifepristone the

abortion medication decision last week I think it was was also based on a lack of standing so

Supreme Court likes to take these off-ramps if they're there especially when they get into messy issues but for now there's no first amendment violation in what the Biden administration did

And Jamie I mean this is also interesting as it pertains to the upcoming well the