Up next in 10
All Engines Go (Almost) Destroyed These Characters + Carly the "Crane Engine" is POINTLESS!
Jun 3, 2025
#thomasandfriends #allenginesgo #carlythecraneengine
View Video Transcript
0:00
the other characters however are now
0:02
mixed in terms of likability and
0:04
personality while they somewhat maintain
0:06
their original counterparts they're also
0:09
mostly changed to different counterparts
0:11
thomas is now a child character who now
0:13
wants to have fun rather than doing work
0:16
and is a bit less cheeky than before
0:18
percy is basically Henry from the Brener
0:21
era a completely scared and wimpy baby
0:23
who also goes along with whatever stupid
0:26
stuff Thomas does annie and Clarabel are
0:29
no longer just Thomas's coaches anymore
0:31
now they can be anyone's coaches now the
0:33
troublesome trucks went from
0:35
troublemaking trucks who love causing
0:36
trouble to being reduced to two one-note
0:39
jokesters that have an elderly duo the
0:41
fat guy Sir Topham Hat is no longer a
0:44
railway controller that appears
0:45
regularly to give the engines their
0:48
tasks and is now just a joke he's dumb
0:51
he screws up and overreacts to
0:53
everything if you thought the Brener era
0:56
made Sir Topham Hat look stupid this
0:58
reboot/show makes him look even stupider
1:01
and just a complete joke diesel is no
1:03
longer the big bad villain who thinks
1:05
Diesels are better than Steamies anymore
1:07
he's now just a redeemed villain and one
1:10
of Thomas's friends with no redemption
1:12
arc and that's not a bad decision at all
1:14
as in the first episode of season 21 it
1:17
looked like he was going to get a
1:18
redemption arc as now won't be bumping
1:20
into engines anymore the problem however
1:23
is that it was undone after that episode
1:26
he just reverted back to being a onenote
1:28
bully again so as a result him being a
1:32
good guy and Thomas's friend in the
1:33
reboot was not earned and was way too
1:35
sudden carly is now a crane engine which
1:38
is not only jarring but also completely
1:41
pointless because Cranky and Barisford
1:43
never turn into crane engines and what's
1:46
even more insulting is that a new
1:47
character called Tess was introduced in
1:50
season 2 and she looks so much like
1:52
Carly so what even was the point if they
1:55
wanted a crane engine into the main cast
1:57
then it would have made more sense if
1:59
they could have easily used Harvey he
2:01
exists rebecca is nowhere to be seen in
2:05
this reboot i'm shocked well done Mattel
2:09
emily transports Sir Topham Hat anywhere
2:12
instead of Winston for the first two
2:14
seasons whiff is now a mad scientist who
2:17
recycles things gordon is now a kind
2:20
father figure which is a welcome change
2:22
of pace but I just wish he was still
2:24
pompous from time to time