How do black holes actually interact with matter?
466 views
Mar 29, 2025
Is information intrinsic in our universe? NASA’s Michelle Thaller explains.
View Video Transcript
0:00
Music
0:00
Black holes really are kind of getting to the very heart of our physics
0:14
and I believe that they're kind of showing us the way that eventually we're going to need different physics and new physics
0:20
People ask questions like, what happens inside a black hole? Or even what happens at the very boundary of a black hole, the event horizon where light is absorbed
0:28
And honestly, our physics is telling us a lot of contradictory things
0:33
And our image of what an event horizon really is may be changing
0:38
People like Stephen Hawking and Leonard Susskind have recently come up with this idea
0:42
that a black hole should not be able to destroy information. Okay, what do we mean by information
0:49
Information can be almost anything. You know, all of the different atoms in my body have angular momentum
0:55
They have charge. They have mass. There's all sorts of little bits of information that make me me
1:03
At the quantum mechanic level, at the tiniest of levels, there are different amounts of energy
1:09
There are different probabilities that are contained in the structure of my matter. And information, in some ways, is a form of energy
1:16
It's actually a way that you can describe something, which is somehow, in a strange way, a higher energy state than not being able to describe something
1:26
And so one of the questions is if energy really can't be destroyed
1:30
energy itself is something that is intrinsic in the universe. You can't really create it or destroy it
1:36
Is it possible that information is the same way? Is there really no way to actually destroy the information
1:42
about what all of my subatomic particles are doing right now? So black holes kind of stare you right in the face
1:49
What a black hole supposedly does it absorbs everything Space and time bend into a black hole so that nothing can escape That means that any information about the material that fell in is gone
2:03
The only thing we know about it is that as a black hole absorbs material, it gets more massive
2:08
It actually adds that mass to the mass of the black hole. And as that mass increases, the event horizon becomes larger
2:17
Basically, the area where space is so curved that you can't get out begins to extend the
2:22
more massive a black hole is. The most massive black holes we know of in the universe are many billions of times the
2:29
mass of our sun. And the physical extent of this event horizon is about the size of our solar system, maybe
2:35
like out to the planet Pluto. So is it possible then if everything goes into a black hole and nothing ever comes out
2:43
space and time go inside the black hole and don't come out. What happened to that information
2:49
And this has begun to make a lot of people wonder if we really have thought of black holes the wrong
2:55
way. Maybe there isn't an event horizon in the true sense. I actually had a friend of mine that
3:00
studies black holes say, well, I'm not sure if they're black. They may be very, very dark navy
3:04
blue. And what he meant by that is maybe there are some tricks to actually get information out
3:10
of a black hole. Maybe there really is some form of energy that can leak away
3:14
from the black hole over time. Now Stephen Hawking wondered if quantum effects very near the event
3:20
horizon could actually separate something called virtual particles, the energy of space itself
3:27
If you're familiar with Einstein's equation, equals mc squared. Energy equals mass times the speed of light squared
3:34
Energy and mass are the same thing. They're equivalent. You can actually make mass into energy
3:39
And you can make energy into mass. Around a black hole where there's very hot gas
3:44
very high temperatures very strong magnetic fields perhaps there a lot of energy And that energy can actually manifest itself as particles mass And the energy always creates particle pairs
3:58
They're called virtual particles. And matter and antimatter, the thing you know about it
4:03
is that it annihilates immediately. So these tiny little particles come into existence
4:07
then annihilate, and you're back to energy. And this happens all around us all the time
4:12
So if this happens near a black hole, It's possible one of these little particles can go into the black hole and the other one escapes
4:19
And all of a sudden there's a particle that shouldn't be there. The universe basically has a new particle, energy from nowhere
4:27
And how can that work? And the information theory people say that what happens is that energy has to come out of the black hole
4:35
The black hole's mass begins to decrease if there is this poor little orphan particle
4:40
that shouldn't have been there in the first place. So over time, tiny particle by tiny particle, these black holes can evaporate away
4:48
And maybe there's something about those virtual particles that contain some information about
4:54
the black hole and what fell into it. It even gets stranger than that because a lot of people think that time goes slower and
5:02
slower as you approach a black hole till at the event horizon, time basically stops
5:08
So instead of anything really ever falling into a black hole, what the event horizon may be is some sort of shell of information
5:16
Things are stopped in time as they fell into the black hole. And right at that boundary, there's almost kind of a sphere
5:23
a two-dimensional surface that somehow contains all the information about what's inside the black hole
5:29
And this reminded people of something that humans invented called a hologram
5:33
Now a hologram is a two dimensional object. You can make it out of glass or a piece of film
5:39
and you shine a light through it, and all of a sudden there seem to be three dimensional projections And the idea is that are we looking at some fundamental way the universe stores information Around a black hole where space and time have been crushed out of
5:54
existence, could there be a shell of information, something like a hologram? And a lot of people
6:02
began to wonder, maybe that's the way the universe works on a larger scale. Maybe black holes are
6:07
showing us intrinsically what the underlying nature of reality is. That there really is a
6:13
two-dimensional surface of something that contains all information about the entire universe. Maybe
6:21
in some way we are part of this giant hologram. And I should mention that the word hologram in no
6:27
way implies that somebody made the hologram. We're just talking about the universe may really be
6:33
information contained in a two-dimensional structure, not the three dimensions that we're
6:38
aware of now. This all sounds incredibly strange. I'm always a little bit afraid to even talk about
6:45
it, but I think that the thing to really kind of gain from this is that black holes are staring us
6:50
right in the face. We're now observing them. They're right there, and we cannot really describe
6:56
how the universe should work with one of these things. They don't make sense
7:00
The universe shouldn't be able to lose information. So how do you get information when space itself are bent in and nothing comes out
7:09
Black holes may be the key to where the next physics has to go. We all know that we need a next Einstein, a next quantum theory
7:17
something that actually describes how gravity works in very intense situations like a black hole
7:22
Now we're actually observing black holes well enough that we really have to get on this
7:27
So we really have to figure out how the universe works around one of these things
7:31
And we may end up learning what the universe itself really is
#Astronomy
#Physics