In diesem Video teste ich 3 Dosentomaten. Dabei sind San Marzano vom Aldi, geschälte von Mutti und Kirschtomaten vom REWE in Bio Qualität.
00:00 Intro
01:00 San Marzano
06:10 geschälte von Mutti
08:27 Bio Kirschtomaten
10:38 Fazit
#test #tomaten #rezept
Show More Show Less View Video Transcript
0:00
Hello and welcome to my channel. Have
0:01
you noticed that there are no more San
0:04
Marzano tomatoes at Rewe or Edeka? Due
0:08
to the BPA levels in cans, I switched
0:10
to tomatoes in jars from Tuscany a
0:13
while ago, but their quality has
0:15
declined. No more chunks of fruit, just
0:18
pureed to death and watery. Yes, for
0:21
this amount, the price is simply too
0:23
high. Almost 3 €. I first blamed it
0:26
on seasonal reasons, but the new
0:28
harvest should be here by now and,
0:29
unfortunately, the quality has remained
0:32
just as poor. San Marzano tomatoes are
0:34
only available in specialty online
0:37
shops or as a promotional item at Aldi.
0:40
In this video, I am testing Mutti
0:42
peeled tomatoes, unpeeled organic
0:44
cherry tomatoes from Rewe, and the San
0:46
Marzano ones from Aldi. They happened
0:49
to be on sale recently. They are also
0:51
test candidate number one. I will test
0:54
the taste plain, then on a pizza, and
0:56
as a pasta sauce. Yes, and this test is
0:59
of course not representative. The Aldi
1:02
San Marzano tomatoes were harvested in
1:05
2025 on day 250, so they are ripe and
1:08
carry the DOP label. So they are the
1:11
original ones from Campania. Here is
1:13
the test plain and on the pizza. And
1:16
yes, that is the first minus point when
1:20
the tab breaks off. Well, it's nice
1:22
when you still have a can opener. Net
1:24
weight, drained weight 240g out of 400g
1:29
. I didn't expect there to be that many
1:32
tomatoes inside. The consistency looks
1:35
quite good. It is perfectly fine for
1:37
spreading on the pizza. I'll take a bit
1:40
of the fruit pulp and a bit of the
1:42
juice. They don't taste particularly
1:44
sweet. Yes, I've put about half of it
1:48
into a smaller bowl now. A little olive
1:51
oil and a bit of fleur de sel. And that
1:54
will now be used directly to make two
1:58
pizzas. Yes, you can already see here
2:02
that it looks a bit watery. I am a fan
2:06
of chorizo, so I'm adding four slices
2:09
of chorizo and leaving a few empty
2:13
spots to test the pure tomato flavor.
2:18
Yes, I added a bit of thyme, but there
2:20
is no heat in it. So, I generally
2:23
skipped chili powder today. I used this
2:27
pizza flour because the one I usually
2:30
use, uh, is this one from Lidl, but I
2:32
can't get it at the moment. No idea why
2:36
. This one from Rewe, I am not that
2:38
satisfied with it. It doesn't absorb as
2:40
much water and only has a 10%protein
2:42
content. It also doesn't rise as nicely
2:45
. I'm making it in a pizza pan, and
2:49
there's that famous demo effect where
2:51
the pizza didn't get as brown on top as
2:54
usual. But in terms of taste, overall
2:59
good so far. On the pizza, the San
3:01
Marzanos from Aldi performed
3:03
outstandingly. One tester gave 10 out
3:05
of 10 and the other tester nine out of
3:08
10 points. The tomatoes had a depth of
3:11
flavor, were not particularly sweet,
3:13
which is good on a pizza, and they
3:15
weren't acidic at all. For the pasta
3:18
sauce, I'm using a simple recipe by
3:20
Steffen Henssler where the tomato takes
3:22
center stage. Here is the preparation.
3:25
For our pasta sauce, we need half a
3:27
small onion and tomato paste. The rest
3:31
of the tomato can, you can of course
3:33
use double the amount, but I only want
3:35
to make two small portions here. A
3:37
little sugar, just a pinch, and a pinch
3:39
of salt. I add about a tablespoon of
3:43
butter for this half can of tomatoes.
3:52
and now we add the onions. That can go
3:57
down a little bit more. So, we let that
4:00
sweat until translucent. After 2
4:03
minutes, we take some tomato paste,
4:08
sweat that along with it. Then go ahead
4:10
and turn the heat up a notch and keep
4:13
stirring well. That brings out the
4:15
sweetness from the tomato paste. After
4:18
one minute, we add the tomatoes and
4:23
turn to the lowest setting. Now comes a
4:28
pinch of sugar and a pinch of salt. We
4:34
let the whole thing simmer gently on a
4:38
low setting for 10 minutes. In parallel
4:42
, I've put on the pasta water and I'm
4:45
making Torchioloni today, because this
4:48
pasta has the advantage of having such
4:51
large holes, which is ideal for a
4:53
tomato sauce. And after 10 minutes, we
4:57
add half a ladle, turn it up once,
5:00
along with the pasta. And now we let
5:04
that sit for a minute to soak through a
5:09
bit. Plating is then simply just Yes,
5:16
you can add a little bit of Parmesan on
5:18
top. I chose Emmentaler, because it's
5:25
not quite as overpowering, and I won't
5:27
put too much on for the eye. Yes.
5:32
Taste-wise. I already nibbled a bit
5:35
earlier, it leans in a fruity direction
5:38
and, in my opinion, there is enough
5:41
fruit pulp and tomato. It definitely
5:43
tastes really delicious and balanced.
5:45
The flavor also had that depth. However
5:48
, I would have liked a bit more
5:49
sweetness. Yes, San Marzano tomatoes
5:52
aren't always the first choice for
5:54
pasta in Italy either, but the rating
5:56
is still impressive. On the pizza, the
5:59
tomatoes were fully convincing. The
6:10
next test candidate is the peeled
6:12
Italian tomatoes from Mutti. The can
6:15
has a design that makes you want to get
6:16
started right away. As the only one in
6:19
the test, they have a net weight of
6:21
260g. Whether that makes a difference,
6:23
here is the test. The can opens up
6:24
easily, for starters. That is not as
6:27
liquid as the San Marzano. I'm always
6:30
curious about that. Yes, and then I
6:32
take the fork again. Yes, so you can
6:37
see they are better than the San
6:40
Marzanos in terms of wateriness. There
6:43
is hardly any water content in there. A
6:45
little bit like that, and then let's
6:47
see. They don't quite have the depth of
6:50
flavor of the San Marzanos and have a
6:52
very slight acidity. Yes, on the
6:55
subject of wateriness, it is very clear
6:58
here that no liquid is being released.
7:02
Today I didn't pile it on so thickly.
7:05
Yes, the first test without chorizo. On
7:09
the pizza, the Mutti tomatoes are a
7:11
good standard with 2 x 7 out of 10
7:13
points. They don't have that depth of
7:16
flavor like the San Marzanos. And then
7:18
came the pasta test. Yes, the tomato
7:21
pasta sauce is sizzling away again, and
7:24
there isn't that much liquid in it.
7:27
There won't be much liquid left in
7:30
there now. After 10 minutes, the pasta
7:32
is done. Pasta water. I'll leave a
7:36
little bit in the ladle and the pasta.
7:38
And we'll let that soak in for a bit
7:40
now. Pasta water is enough. We don't
7:43
want to make it too thin. This is
7:46
binding nicely with the fruit pulp now.
7:48
Today I preheated the plates. Yes, this
7:53
is pasta dish number two. Let's test it
7:56
. Tomatoey and balanced. The taste was
8:00
good. Here too, there were two times 7
8:03
out of 10 points. In the pasta sauce,
8:05
the Mutti tomatoes were only narrowly
8:07
inferior to the San Marzanos. The
8:10
evaluation shows a good result overall.
8:13
They offer a good taste, but aren't as
8:15
suitable for sauces due to their
8:17
compact mass. The last test candidate
8:29
is the organic cherry tomatoes from
8:31
Rewe. They should be on the sweeter
8:33
side and therefore well-suited for a
8:35
pasta sauce. Let's go. Yes, it's a bit
8:39
more liquid, and because they are so
8:42
small, the skin isn't as tough or as
8:44
large. The drained weight is 240 grams
8:47
here as well. That's a standard value.
8:50
You can see by the consistency that
8:52
there is a certain amount of liquid in
8:53
there. But that's more like tomato
8:55
juice. The taste is not that sweet, has
8:59
a certain harmonious acidity. Yes, I
9:02
find the water content here is one of
9:04
the best. It's not as thick as the
9:06
Mutti ones and not as liquid as the San
9:08
Marzanos. And then we have the next
9:13
pizza, number 3. And here we go. So
9:16
without chorizo, tomatoey, but not as
9:19
sweet as I thought. The taste of cherry
9:21
tomatoes is a bit intense for me. A mix
9:24
of sweetness and acidity. Both testers
9:27
therefore gave it a six each. The
9:30
tomato skins weren't a problem, but in
9:32
my opinion, these tomatoes have no
9:35
place on a pizza. But in the pasta
9:38
sauce, that should work out. Yes, it's
9:40
already sizzling away nicely again.
9:44
There isn't that much liquid. So I have
9:47
to set it aside again after a certain
9:49
time. Yes. And we add some pasta water
9:52
again. And I've turned the heat on for
9:56
the pasta. The tomato juice had already
9:59
reduced quite a bit, so it really made
10:01
a difference. Visually, it turned out
10:03
great once again. The tomatoes really
10:06
come through very well in the pasta
10:08
dish. I forgot to preheat the plates
10:10
today. Also bent here. The taste met my
10:13
expectations. In the rating, there was
10:16
a six and a seven. The overall rating
10:18
is just below the Mutti tomatoes.
10:20
However, they also cost only half as
10:22
much. Cherry tomatoes have a specific
10:24
taste; you have to like that. That has
10:26
nothing to do with this variety from
10:28
Rewe. It wasn't for us. In the overall
10:40
rating, the San Marzano from Aldi
10:42
clearly won, even though they lagged
10:44
behind in wateriness and consistency.
10:47
The taste was clearly the best. Mutti
10:50
tomatoes are more expensive, but in my
10:53
opinion, offer no advantage in taste.
10:56
And that is why I recommend testing
10:58
these tomatoes from Rewe. Whole peeled
11:01
Italian organic tomatoes at half the
11:03
price of the Mutti tomatoes. That's it
11:06
for today. Take care. See you next time
11:08
. Bye.
Cooking & Recipes
Hobbies & Leisure

